The Means of Inadmissibility

Written by Carlos Felipe17 min read

Images for post 59
Images for post 59

Addressing the definition of grounds for inadmissibility, Guy Block defines the purpose of inadmissibility as: A means of defense that prevents the judge from ruling on the merits of a claim , when the judge is competent and duly empowered . In this sense, we can see that when a ground for inadmissibility is invoked, the court's jurisdiction has already been established and it has been properly empowered, thus providing the precise moment for the parties to file this motion , which prevents the court from considering the merits of the case, due to one of the grounds that may give rise to such a motion.

The grounds for inadmissibility under Law 834, in accordance with Articles 44 to 48 of Law 834, constitute any ground that tends to declare the opposing party's claim inadmissible without examining the merits, due to lack of standing to act, such as lack of capacity, lack of interest , fulfillment of the statute of limitations , the expiration of the predetermined term for the fulfillment of a procedural act or compromising the proceedings , or res judicata.

Objections to the admissibility of a case may be raised at any stage of the proceedings, but the judge has the power to order the payment of damages to the litigant who, with dilatory intent, has refrained from invoking such grounds for inadmissibility beforehand.

The party invoking them is not obligated to justify a grievance, even if the inadmissibility does not result from an express provision. The judge must address these issues ex officio when they are matters of public order, especially when they result from non-compliance with the time limits for exercising the appeal process.

The provisions of Law 834 expressly indicate that the judge may supply ex officio the means of inadmissibility resulting from the lack of interest.

When the situation that has given rise to a means of inadmissibility is susceptible to being regularized, the inadmissibility is considered improper, if its cause has disappeared at the time the judge rules, as well as in the case that, before the exclusion, the person who has the capacity to act becomes a party to the instance.

The preceding provisions correspond in the text of Law 834 to a literal, sometimes incorrect, translation of Articles 122 to 126 of the New French Code of Civil Procedure.

The three elements that BLOCK identifies in its definition are: 1. The limits of its scope of application; it is a means of defense that challenges a claim; 2. Its procedural function: it prevents a ruling on the merits of the claim; 3. Its place in the process: it cannot be applied until the preceding logical stages of the process have been completed, namely, that the judge is competent and duly authorized to hear the case. Thus, we observe that it attacks not so much the claim itself, but rather the knowledge of the claim, since the objective of this means is to prevent the claim from being heard, and therefore, with respect to procedural matters, to prevent the judge from ruling on the merits of the case. We also observe that, in this way, this means must be filed at the precise and logical procedural moment, which is after verifying the court's jurisdiction and authorization to hear the case.

GROUNDS FOR INADMISSIBILITY. According to the Code of Civil Procedure, the grounds for inadmissibility, or inadmissibility, that the defendant could raise against the claim operated from various perspectives, in a manner distinct from exceptions and defenses. These included, and still include, among others: lack of interest, capacity, or standing; the inadmissibility of an appeal due to being late (Art. 444 of the Code of Civil Procedure) or premature (Art. 449, repealed); and the cases provided for in Arts. 27 and 497 of the Code of Civil Procedure, and 105, 435, 518, and 581 of the Commercial Code.

While it is true that we understand the distinction of the means of inadmissibility, it is no less true that these means, distinguished by the jurist Froilan Tavares, are currently the main ones existing in our legislation, so we have to keep in mind that the means of inadmissibility are not limited, or confined to the law.

In the same vein, the distinguished jurist points out that when opposing one of these means, the defendant does not directly attack the existence of the right, the power or the legal situation on which the plaintiff bases his action, nor does he challenge the regularity of the procedure, but rather adds to the plaintiff the right of action in justice.

Hence the following characteristics of the means of inadmissibility that distinguish them from defenses and exceptions:
1. When accepting a motion to dismiss, the judge does not examine the merits of the claim as they would when accepting a defense, but rather declares it inadmissible because the plaintiff lacks standing. Once declared inadmissible, the claim, as a general rule, cannot be refiled, as occurs when the judge accepts an objection.
2. The means of inadmissibility could, according to the Code of Civil Procedure, be invoked at any stage of the proceedings, just like the defenses; on the contrary, the exceptions had to be invoked before the defenses on the merits, and before the means of inadmissibility.
3. The judgment that, in the hearing of the defendant's conclusions on the merits, rejects a means of inadmissibility linked to the merits, is contradictory and not in default, according to the most widespread opinion.

The aforementioned characteristics, generally attributed to grounds for inadmissibility, as opposed to exceptions and defenses respectively, do not, according to most authors, justify considering them an independent category of grounds occupying an intermediate position between the two. In most cases, in fact, according to the system of the Code of Civil Procedure, the rules governing grounds for inadmissibility were the same as those governing substantive defenses.
Some of the grounds for inadmissibility operated more like exceptions than defenses; for example, the ground of inadmissibility due to being premature. from the appeal provided for in art. 449, repealed, since the judgment that accepted it deprived the appellant of the right to initiate another appeal

The Means of Inadmissibility and the Preliminary Draft of the Code of Civil Procedure.

GROUNDS FOR INADMISSIBILITY AS INCIDENTS OF CIVIL PROCEEDINGS:

Law 834-78 did not specify the incidental nature of the grounds for inadmissibility, although it clearly established the tripartite classification of defenses, exceptions, and grounds for inadmissibility, as proposed by French legal doctrine. The ACPC expressly includes grounds for inadmissibility among the incidental matters: (...) an incidental matter shall be understood as: any request accessory to a process already initiated, related to the formalities or the substance of the claim or that seeks to have it declared inadmissible without examination of the merits (...); Although the Honorable Magistrate expressed this, we understand that, even if details were lacking, Law 834 of 1978 deals with grounds for inadmissibility.

II. DEFINITION AND POSITION OF THE MEANS OF INADMISSIBILITY:

Article 248 of the ACPC contains the following definition of the means of inadmissibility:

Any means that tends to have the opposing party's claim declared inadmissible, without examination of the merits, constitutes an inadmissibility (...).

A superficial reading of Article 248 of the ACPC would lead us to conclude that it reproduces Article 44 of Law 834-78 verbatim. However, comparing the two texts reveals that the ACPC omits the phrase "For lack of standing to sue," which appears in the aforementioned Article 44 of Law 834-78. But it not only omits it, it also shifts it to paragraph 1 of Article 300, which heads the exceptions of nullity for substantive irregularities. This shift is, in my view, erroneous, because the key, essential, fundamental difference between exceptions of nullity and grounds for inadmissibility is that the latter attack the very right to bring an action in court, while exceptions of nullity attack procedural acts.

The position I hold is classic: it can be found in the old Legal Vocabulary, compiled under the direction of Henri Capitant, and in the more recent dictionaries of Raymond Guillién and Jean Vincent, Remy Cabrillac, and Gérard Cornu. It is also the criterion that underpins a settled doctrine.
Guy Block, quoting Henri Matulsky, one of the great figures of 20th-century French procedural law, states:

(…) it is within the domain of the action and the means of inadmissibility, any procedural factor that, on the one hand, does not concern the progress of the process and that, on the other hand, does not raise the issue of the well-founded nature of the claim, nor particularly the reality of the substantive right claimed.

If the wording of article 300, numeral 1, paragraph I is maintained, it would enter into a clear contradiction with article 64 of the ACPC itself, which defines the action in justice in the following way:

For the party with a claim, legal action is the right to be heard so that the court can decide whether it is well-founded or not. For the opposing party, legal action is the right to challenge the basis of that claim. (emphasis added)

What we are stating is reinforced by the very clear provision of Article 66 of the ACPC itself:

Any action brought by or against a person without the right to bring an action is inadmissible.

III. THE NATURE OF THE ENUMERATION IN ARTICLE 248 OF THE ACPC:

As in the regime of Law 834-78, the merely illustrative nature of the grounds for inadmissibility is maintained, which, as we have stated elsewhere in this work, are scattered throughout many texts. Several grounds for inadmissibility can be gleaned from the ACPC itself:

  • As we already said, the lack of right to act in justice (art. 66);
  • Inadmissibility of the previously proposed incidents on the same cause (art. 138, numeral 7);
  • Inadmissibility of the intervention when it lacks the required requirements (art. 138, numeral 8);
  • Inadmissibility of the exception of lack of jurisdiction without justification (art. 252);
  • Inadmissibility of the nullity of an act, whose proponent has consented to it, even tacitly (art. 294);
  • The challenge of a judge, under penalty of inadmissibility, must be made as soon as the cause of challenge is known (art. 310);
  • The content of the recusal document is subject to inadmissibility (art. 314);
  • The appeal in cassation is inadmissible when the appeal is open (art. 563, paragraph I);
  • An appeal filed late is inadmissible (art. 568);
  • New claims are inadmissible on appeal, in principle (art. 569);
  • The third-party incidental appeal is inadmissible after the presentation of conclusions (art. 596, paragraph V);
  • The appeal in cassation is inadmissible: 1) filed after two months (art. 615); 2) the appeal that does not specify the grievances (art. 615, paragraph);
  • Failure to file the appeal brief within two months (art. 616);
  • In the seizure of tangible personal property: 1) the failure to notify the depositary and the creditor of the opposition to the sale by a claimant (art. 880); 2) the actions initiated by an opposing creditor against persons other than the one whose property has been seized (art. 883);
  • In the executive seizure of intangible assets and rights, the opposition made against all the clauses of the terms and conditions or drafted in general terms, or which does not indicate which clauses are challenged, or which lacks specific grounds (art. 968, paragraph IV);
  • In the attachment: 1) the accumulation of attachments after the 5-day period following the notification of the terms and conditions has expired (art. 1049, paragraph I); 2) the action for annulment against the adjudication judgment outside the two-month period from the notification (art. 1054, paragraph I); 3) the appeal, when applicable, against the adjudication decision outside the 15-day period (art. 1056);
  • Failure to notify the parties in default before demanding an accounting (art. 1240);
  • The lack of two requirements for issuing a judgment in the claims for denial of justice (art. 1275);
  • Actions that cannot be object of arbitration (Art. 1305).

IV. THE ELIMINATION OF THE PROVISIONS OF ARTICLE 45 OF LAW 834-78

Article 45 of Law 834-78 reads as follows:

Objections to the admissibility of a case may be raised at any stage of the proceedings, except for the possibility for the judge to order damages against those who have refrained, with dilatory intent, from invoking them.

The ACPC makes a clean sweep of the provision we have copied, which seems to us to be a mistake:

a) First, the inclusion of the provision in Article 45 of the current law is neither innocent nor superfluous. It seeks to sanction, through inadmissibility, the lack of an element inherent in every claim: the lack of a right to initiate the action. Therefore, in the interest of procedural prophylaxis and economy, the litigant must be given the power to raise this objection "at any stage of the proceedings."

b) The provision of Article 45 is dynamically linked in Law 834 to the possibility of regularizing the inadmissibility provision. This is precisely what Articles 48 of Law 834-78 and 251 of the ACPC do.

The foregoing considerations lead us to suggest that Article 45 of Law 834-78 be maintained, in order to avoid doubts and possible shifts in jurisprudence.

V. THE GRIEVANCE:

For exceptions of nullity due to procedural defects, the ACPC maintains the criterion of the second paragraph of Article 37 of Law 834-78, in the sense that whoever invokes a nullity of mere form must prove the harm caused to them (Art. 290 ACPC). For inadmissibility, the ACPC maintains in its Article 249 the solution of Article 46 of Law 834-78.

VI. PROPOSAL OF THE MEANS OF INADMISSIBILITY:

Under Law 834-78, as we have already seen, a clear distinction is made between grounds for inadmissibility that can be raised at the request of the parties and those that can be raised ex officio. Grounds of inadmissibility that may be invoked ex officio are those of a public policy nature, such as failure to comply with the time limits for exercising the means of appeal (Art. 47). The court may also raise objections ex officio (Art. 47, second paragraph, Law 834-78).
In France, Decree No. 2004-836 of August 20, 2004, in its article 3, added a paragraph to article 125 of the Code of Civil Procedure (equivalent to article 47 of Law 834-78) worded as follows:

The judge may, ex officio, supply the grounds for inadmissibility based on lack of interest, lack of quality, or res judicata.
At this point, the ACPC is progressive. It empowers the judge to invoke any grounds for inadmissibility ex officio. This is stipulated in Article 250:

The grounds for inadmissibility may be invoked by the parties or pronounced ex officio.

This ratifies the provision contained in paragraph 1 of article 138:

Declare the claim inadmissible, at the request of a party or ex officio.

Both Article 138, paragraph 1, and Article 250 indicate that it is a mere power for the court.

What happens next for the parties when the judge, on his own initiative, supplies a means of inadmissibility?

The ACPC has established a common solution for all incidents: before issuing a ruling, the lawyers appointed by the parties will be notified, so that from the date of said notification, within a period of five days, they may formulate their objections, by means of a written submission to the court, a novel solution that is in accordance with the principles of equality, balance and guarantee proclaimed by the ACPC in the fundamental principles of the process.

VII. PRINCIPLE OF SIMULTANEITY:

Articles 224 paragraph IV and 243 make the promotion of incidents conditional upon them being presented jointly – at the same time and on a single occasion – which obviously includes the means of inadmissibility.

VIII. FORMS OF PROPOSING GROUNDS FOR INADMISSIBILITY:

In Dominican forensic practice, motions are usually presented orally in court. The dynamics of the civil procedure established in the ACPC do not allow for the oral presentation of motions. Besides the fact that they must be presented jointly, simultaneously, and on a single occasion, motions to dismiss, like other motions, are subject to the following mandatory formal requirements ("will they be presented?", "will it be notified?"):

a) They will be proposed by means of a written document addressed to the court, with deposit in the secretariat (art. 224, Paragraph I and 243);
b) The document will be notified to the opposing counsel, by act of counsel to counsel (art. 224, paragraph II and art. 243, paragraph);

c) The defendant in the incidents will also assert his means of defense in writing (art. 224, paragraph IV and 244);

d) For the ruling, the judge has two options: either he rules them in a hearing (art. 224, paragraph, art. 246), or he may grant the parties a period of no more than 15 days, for the production of a written justification of their respective conclusions if the complexity of the matter requires it (art. 224, paragraph VI);

IX. REGULARIZATION OF THE MEANS OF INADMISSION:

The ACPC merely reproduces literally or almost literally the provision of article 48 of Law 834-78.

X. NO CUMULUS OF INADMITTANCE MEANS:

In the provisions common to incidents (arts. 242 to 247) the ACPC proclaims a policy of procedural economy by establishing that incidents may be accumulated to be decided:

Together with the judgment on the merits of the claim.

But the text expressly establishes two exceptions: the grounds for inadmissibility and the exception of unconstitutionality cannot be combined (art. 247), a prohibition that had already been proclaimed in article 224, paragraph V:

The grounds for inadmissibility and the exception of unconstitutionality will be decided separately and by a judgment different from the judgment on the merits. They cannot be combined to be decided jointly with the merits (…) (emphasis mine).

On several occasions we have taken the position that the grounds for inadmissibility should be combined with the substance of the response, which relieves us of further comment here. However, we must point out that the ACPC mitigates the strictness of the rule against combining grounds. Indeed, Article 214 provides the following:

Judgments rendered in incidental proceedings, incidental claims, and investigative measures are not subject to any separate appeal from the appeals against the judgment that decides the merits of the dispute.

Article 225 follows the same line of thought and, like Article 214, contains a lapidary formula:
Any appeal filed before this date will be considered to have no effect on the continuation of the process.

These solutions have the merit of preventing inadmissibility means from becoming a cover for legal trickery.

In Santo Domingo, Dominican Republic, we have the most comprehensive and effective team of lawyers to advise you on matters of Civil Procedure and Common Law. Here at Carlos Felipe Law Firm SRL , we evaluate your case free of charge and without obligation. Call us at 809-847-8731 or write to us at info@fc-abogados.com . You can also chat with us here.

Almost everything in law has a deadline, and yours is already running

Tell us what happened. We'll tell you which path applies and what to do right away, at no cost.

Evaluate my case
We reply within 24 hours

Tell us what is going on

Describe it in your own words. You don't need to know the legal term or have every document. Within 24 hours you will hear back on the options that apply and the deadlines that are running.

Also by phone, Monday to Friday from 8:00 am to 5:00 pm: +1 (809) 847-8731

Free case review