Arbitration is an alternative method of conflict resolution

Written by Carlos Felipe77 min read

El arbitration is the method by which a is subjected conflict to a
third or impartial third parties chosen according to the mechanism
accepted by the parties, who agree to abide by the decision rendered by the
or they, after exhausting the proceedings agreed.

Disputes concerning matters of spirit
provision y transaction, as seen here civil and commercial provisions
applicable, including those in which the the State was part.

The Arbitration Agreement is one by which the parties decide to submit to
arbitration certain or all existing or future disputes
among them, with respect to a particular legal relationship, contractual or
non-contractual. The Arbitration Agreement may adopt la crafts of a
arbitration clause included in a contract or the form of an agreement
Independent.

Arbitration has several classifications, the one of Most significance in the
map Local referees are the Ad-hoc Arbitration and the InstitutionalIn ad hoc arbitration
The parties agree on the applicable procedural rules in the solution
of its disputeWhereas in institutional arbitration, the parties
They submit to a procedure established by an arbitration center.

There is also Arbitration in Law, in which the arbitrators base their decisions
their decision in the current positive law and the Equity Arbitration in which
The arbitrators, at the request of the parties, decide according to common sense and
equity.

In our country, ad hoc arbitration is regulated by Law 489-
08 dated December 19, 2008, which repealed articles 1003 and
the following of the Code of Civil Procedure in force in the Republic
Dominican.

Institutional Arbitration, specifically that of the Resolution Center
Alternative Dispute Resolution of the Chamber of Commerce and Production
Santo Domingo is regulated by both Law 489-08 and by
Law 50-87, dated June 4, 1987, on Official Chambers of
Trade and Production of the Republic, as amended by Law 181-09, the
Regulations of the Conciliation and Arbitration Council of the Chamber of
Santo Domingo Trade and Production, the Procedural Regulations
Internal staff of the Santo Domingo Chamber of Commerce and Production, the
Regulations for Conciliation and Mediation, Guidelines for Arbitrators
of the Conciliation and Arbitration Council of the Chamber of Commerce and
Production of Santo Domingo and the Code of Ethics for Referees.

The final decisions issued by the referees regarding the
disputed issues in the arbitration clause or agreement
known as an Arbitral Award.

Arbitral awards have only one avenue of appeal, which is the
Action for Nullity.

ARBITRATION AS AN ALTERNATIVE METHOD OF DISPUTE RESOLUTION

CONFLICTS

CHAPTER I: GENERAL ASPECTS OF ARBITRATION:

What is arbitration?

Henry Capitant defines arbitration as a modality (sometimes called
friendly or peaceful, but always jurisdictional) to settle a dispute by
an authority (the referee(s)), who are empowered to decide not in
by virtue of a permanent delegation from the State or an institution
international, but from the agreement or convention of the parties (which
They can be simple individuals or also States)1.

1 Capitant, Henry. Legal Vocabulary, 2nd Edition, Temis SA, 1995. Santa Fe. P.71

It is a legal figure of great importance in the commercial field, since
which constitutes a real alternative for a suitable solution,
to quickly and definitively resolve conflicts that arise in transactions
national and international trade.

The Arbitration Regulations of the Conciliation and Arbitration Council of the
Santo Domingo Chamber of Commerce and Production defines arbitration
such as the method by which a conflict is submitted to a third party or
impartial third parties chosen according to the mechanism accepted by the
parties, who agree to abide by the decision rendered by him or them, after
the agreed procedure has been exhausted.

Regulations through the Law and subsequent articles of the Code of Civil Procedure currently in force in the Dominican Republic. These regulations provide new guidelines for commercial relations.
Dominican Republic and was created out of the need for Dominican legislation on arbitration to be in accordance with international regulations on arbitration.

This law is based on Spanish law number 60/2003, dated 23 of
December, inspired by the model law drawn up by the Commission of the
United Nations Convention on International Trade Law in 1985 and
This, in turn, in the statement of reasons for Article V of the
New York Convention of 1958, on the recognition and enforcement of
awards in civil and commercial matters2.

2 Bergés Martín, José de Jesús: The Action for Annulment Against the Arbitral Award of the Center of
Alternative Dispute Resolution. P.1

Matters Subject to Arbitration

Article 2 of Law 489-08, entitled “matter subject to arbitration”
It provides that disputes concerning matters may be submitted to arbitration.
freely disposable and transactable, in accordance with civil provisions and
applicable trade agreements, including those in which the State is
go.

When the arbitration is international and one of the parties is the State
Dominican or a foreigner, or a society, organization or company
owned or controlled by a State, that party may not invoke the
prerogatives of their own right or principle of sovereignty, to
to evade the obligations arising from the arbitration agreement.

Matters Excluded from Arbitration

Article 3 of Law 489-08, entitled “Matters excluded from
The "Arbitration" rule states that the following cannot be subject to arbitration:

Those conflicts related to the civil status of persons,
gifts and bequests of food, lodging and clothing, separations
between husband and wife, guardianships, minors and those under interdiction or
absent.

Cases concerning public order.

All those conflicts that are not susceptible to settlement.

Types of Arbitration

International arbitration

An arbitration is called international because it transcends the spheres of a
unique state and presents links or connections with other states.3

3 Virgós, Miguel. International Commercial Arbitration and the 1958 New York Convention. P. 25.

These connections can be used to measure the degree of proximity of the
arbitration to each of those States, with a view to attributing its regulation to
State that represents the connection that we consider most significant;
But these same connections can also be used in the opposite direction.
On the contrary, as an expression of the distancing of arbitration from the sphere
exclusive to each of those States.

Connections can be used to link arbitration to a State
determined and at the same time place it above the ordinances
national; thus considering that international transactions are not
belong to a specific state, but rather develop within the
interaction of multiple networks of national and international legal orders
international, public and private.

Article 1 of Law 489-08 establishes that arbitration is international in
three circumstances:

. The parties at the time of the conclusion of the arbitration agreement, have
their settlement in different states.

The parties are domiciled outside the Dominican Republic.

The place of performance or fulfillment of a substantial part of the
obligations of the commercial relationship are in a State other than
the one in which they have their domiciles.

National Arbitration

National arbitration is understood to be that in which, as opposed to arbitration, there is no arbitration.
international, a single State intervenes and there is no link or
connections with other States.

Ad-hoc Arbitration

In ad hoc arbitration, the parties have the possibility of establishing, by
if alone, the rules applicable to their specific dispute, in such a way
that the procedure responds to the characteristics of the latter and the
realities of their business operation.

4 Conceptual Framework of International Commercial Arbitration, p. 50

5 Capitant, Henry. Legal Vocabulary. 2nd Edition, Temis SA, 1995, Santa Fe P. 71

Ad-hoc arbitration is usually agreed upon in an arbitration clause
contained in the contractual text of a complex legal transaction between a
private individual and a state entity, as is usually the case in projects
of infrastructure construction or in concession contracts. In the
Ad-hoc arbitration, the arbitration clause, instead of being a
stipulation whose sole purpose is to agree to the subjection of a difference
future submission to an arbitration tribunal constitutes a resolution manual
conflicts in which the parties establish different mechanisms of
approach before resorting to arbitration.

Henry Capitant5 defines ad hoc arbitration as that which is carried out
outside of any permanent arbitration organization and dependent on
the sole initiative of the parties and their arbitrators.

Article 4 of Law 489-08 dated December 19, 2008 defines it
such as one in which the parties agree on the rules of procedure
applicable in the resolution of your dispute.

This type of arbitration is regulated by Law 489-08 dated 19
of December 2008 that repealed articles 1003 et seq. of the Code
of Civil Procedure in force in the Dominican Republic.
Institutional Arbitration

Institutional Arbitration occurs when the parties stipulate that the
The arbitration proceedings will be administered by an Arbitration Center of
in accordance with its arbitration rules. Here there is greater
concern of the parties to have a predictable procedural framework,
that by having a set of rules that, despite its flexibility, does not
They are always applicable throughout the arbitration process.6

6 Conceptual Framework of International Commercial Arbitration, Page 52

7 Capitant, Henry. Legal Vocabulary. 2nd Edition, Temis SA, 1995, Santa Fe P. 72

Just as Ad-hoc Arbitration is defined in Article 4 of the
Law 489-08. It is that in which the parties submit to a procedure
established by an Arbitration Center.

Henry Capitant7 states that this type of arbitration involves intervention
of a permanent arbitration body (Stock Exchange, Chamber of Commerce,
International Trade, Permanent Court of The Hague for Disputes
between States), which makes available to litigants a list of
referees, a set of arbitration rules, a material organization (secretariat,
premises, etc.) and services (notification of allegations, for example).

It is regulated by Law 50-87 of June 4, 1987, on
Official Chambers of Commerce and Production of the Republic, as well as by
Law 181-09, which introduces modifications to said law, and by the
Arbitration Regulations of the Conciliation and Arbitration Council of the
Santo Domingo Chamber of Commerce, now Resolution Center
Alternative Dispute Resolution of the Chamber of Commerce and Production
Santo Domingo.

Arbitration in Law

Article 4 of Law 489-08 defines it as that in which the arbitrators
They base their decision on current positive law.

The Arbitration Regulations of the Conciliation and Arbitration Council of the
Santo Domingo Chamber of Commerce and Production, in its article 2
This type of arbitration is defined as one in which the arbitrators are in the
obligation to conduct oneself and make decisions based on legal norms and
applicable procedural rules.

In the absence of an express agreement between the parties on the type of arbitration to which
wish to submit (in law or in equity), arbitration will prevail in
right.

Equity arbitration

Law 489-08 defines it as that in which the arbitrators decide according to the
common sense and fairness.

The Arbitration Regulations of the Conciliation and Arbitration Council of the
Santo Domingo Chamber of Commerce and Production, in its article 2
defined as that which takes place when the parties expressly
empower the arbitrator or arbitrators to decide as an amicable mediator, ex
aequo et bono, according to the best of their knowledge and belief.

CHAPTER II: THE ARBITRATION AGREEMENT AND THE COMPOSITION OF THE
TRIBUNAL

Definition of the arbitration agreement

Article 10 of Law 489-08 defines it as an agreement by which the
parties decide to submit to arbitration certain or all of the disputes that
there are or may arise between them, with respect to a certain relationship
legal, contractual or non-contractual. The Arbitration Agreement may
take the form of an arbitration clause included in a contract or the
form of an independent agreement.

The Arbitration Regulations of the Conciliation and Arbitration Council of the
The Santo Domingo Chamber of Commerce and Production defines it as the
agreement by which the parties commit themselves, either in a
contract or document of a similar nature to be submitted to the jurisdiction
arbitration is the solution to their unborn differences.

Form of the arbitration agreement

The form of the arbitration agreement is regulated by the provisions
of article 10 of law 489-08, which provides the following:

It must be in writing. The agreement will be considered to be in writing.
when it is stated in a document signed by the parties or
in an exchange of letters, faxes, telegrams, emails
or other means of telecommunication that record the
agreement and be accessible for further consultation in support
electronic, optical or other type.

The agreement is considered incorporated into the agreement between the parties.
arbitration that is contained in a document to which these have been referred
in any of the ways established in the previous apparatus.

A written agreement will be considered to exist when it is recorded in
an exchange of pleadings and defenses within the process
arbitration in which the existence of the agreement is affirmed by a
part and not denied by the other.

In international arbitration, the arbitration agreement will be valid and the
The dispute will be subject to arbitration if the requirements are met.
established by the legal rules chosen by the parties for
governed by the arbitration agreement, or by the legal rules applicable to
substance of the controversy, or by Dominican law.

Object

The subject matter of the arbitration is contained within the provisions of
Article 2 of Law 489-08, whose provisions establish that:

Disputes concerning matters of
free disposal and transaction, in accordance with civil provisions
and applicable trade agreements, including those in which the State
was a party.

When the arbitration is international and one of the parties is the
Dominican state or a foreign state, or a company,
organization or company owned or controlled by a State, that
a party may not invoke the prerogatives of its own right or

Principle of sovereignty, to avoid obligations
emanating from the arbitration agreement.

Effects

The main effect of the arbitration agreement is to compel the parties to resort to
arbitration to resolve all disputes. French doctrine splits
This result has two effects: one positive and one negative.
In general terms, the positive effect consists of giving jurisdiction to
arbitral tribunal. Similarly, the negative imposes a duty on the
Judges in the absence of an arbitration agreement would be competent, if they ceased to
to understand the controversy.

Number of referees

Article 14 of Law 489-08 provides that the parties may determine
freely choose the number of referees, under the requirement that that number must
be odd. When there is no agreement between the parties on the number of
arbitrators, a single arbitrator shall be appointed.

Appointment of arbitrators: the receptum arbitrii

The receptum arbitrii, in accordance with the provisions of the Regulations of
United Nations Commission on International Commercial Arbitration8,
It consists of submitting the task to one or more people for their acceptance.
to judge a dispute according to law or equity, as appropriate.
between parties.

8 Alarcón, Edynson. Judicial Gazette Magazine. Dec. 2009.

Article 15 of Law 489-08 establishes that the parties may designate
the arbitrators directly and by mutual agreement or delegate to a third party,
natural or legal person, the total or partial designation of the arbitrators.

In ad hoc arbitration with three or more arbitrators, each party shall appoint the
referees that correspond proportionally and the missing referee will be
appointed by the selected arbitrators, who will preside over the tribunal
arbitral.

In the absence of an agreement between the parties or the arbitrators, when the same is
provided that the following rules will apply:

In the case of institutional arbitration, the arbitrators will be
appointed in accordance with the regulations of the arbitral institution that
correspond.

In ad-hoc arbitration with one or more arbitrators, these will be
appointed by the competent court, at the request of one of the
parts.

The court may only reject the request made when
appreciate that the documents provided do not show the existence of a
arbitration agreement.

If the court appoints arbitrators, it will take into account
the requirements established by the parties to be arbitrators as well as the
Regarding the matter of the response, it will take the necessary measures to guarantee
their independence and impartiality.

Against the final awards that decide on the issues attributed
In this article, no appeal will be permitted to the competent court, except
those who reject the request made in accordance with the
section 4.

Inhibition

Article 16 of Law 489-08 establishes that every person who is
The appointed arbitrator must disclose in writing all the circumstances
that may give rise to justifiable doubts about their impartiality or
Independence. The referee, from the moment of their appointment and
during all arbitration proceedings, shall promptly disclose such
circumstances to the parties.

challenge

The provisions of article 16.2 of Law 489-08 establish that a
The referee may only be challenged if there are circumstances that give rise to
justifiable doubts regarding their impartiality or independence, or if not
possesses the requirements agreed upon by the parties. A party may only
to challenge the arbitrator appointed by it, or in whose appointment it has
participated, for reasons of which I became aware after
the designation has been made.

Regarding the procedure for recusal, Law 489-08 establishes,
In its article 17, in the case of ad-hoc arbitration, the parties may agree
freely the procedure for challenging arbitrators.

In the absence of such an agreement, the party wishing to challenge an arbitrator shall state
to the arbitral tribunal, by means of a written request, the reasons for the
recusal, within fifteen (15) days following the one in which he/she has
knowledge of the acceptance or that you have knowledge of any
of the circumstances that may give rise to justifiable doubts about his
impartiality or independence.

If the challenge initiated in accordance with the procedure does not succeed
agreed by the parties, or as established in the preceding paragraph, the party
The recuser may appeal in the sole and final instance to the court of
council, before the Court of Appeal of the Department of the place of
arbitration. The same procedure must be followed in the case of the appointment of a
sole arbitrator or challenge of the entire arbitral tribunal.

CHAPTER III: THE COMPETENCE OF REFEREES AND THE
SUBSTANTIATION OF HIS ACTIONS:

The “kompetenz-kompentenz” rule and its scope

The principle “kompetenz-kompentenz” means competence over the
competition and has its origin in the New York Convention of 1958.
The positive effect of this principle attributes to the arbitrators the power to know about the
validity on which its authority is based.

There is a marked doctrinal tendency, especially in countries
foreigners, to conceptualize (for evaluation purposes) and separate what
These were the agreements and intentions of the Parties that sign a Contract,
As follows:

1) will subject matter of the Contract and

2) will subject to the arbitration clause.

In other words, for the doctrine there is a marked difference in the object of the
arbitration clause and the subject matter of the agreement or contract itself on which it is based
has reflected the desire of the parties to submit future disputes to
arbitrators and/or arbitration9. This is so, since the will of the parties and the
The very object of these is markedly different from the Contract and
to the arbitration clause. This differentiation is important, since
as understood by the French Court of Cassation in the Gosset case10 “the
The nullity of the main contract did not entail the nullity of the arbitration agreement,
if the main contract is international”11

9 Samuel, Adam. “Separability in English law: should an arbitration clause be regarded as
an agreement separate and collateral to a contract in which it is contained?” 3 Journal of
International Arbitration, 1986, p. 109.

10 May 7, 1963 Clunet 82, cited by Samuel op.cit. p.99

11 Tolero Rueda, Santiago. International Commercial Arbitration, Temis Publishing House, Bogotá
Colombia, year 2008, p.139,140.

It is within this context that the principle of “Kompetenz-
Kompetenz.” This principle essentially states that referees are
the judges within their own jurisdiction. This is also assumed by Law 489-08.
especially in its article 20, which deals with the competence of
arbitration tribunal. That is to say, it is not within the jurisdiction of the ordinary judge.
and/or to the ordinary courts to determine the validity or invalidity of a
arbitration clause or declare the jurisdiction of the arbitral tribunal. By the
On the contrary, it is up to the referees themselves whose jurisdiction is being disputed or is
ventilate, determine whether or not they themselves are competent to know and
to resolve the dispute in question. In that same sense, it is worth dividing
The scope of the aforementioned principle is as follows:

(i) It is within the competence of the arbitrators to determine, at least
provisionally, the existence and validity of the agreement or clause
arbitration. This also includes determining whether the dispute is
The issue concerns the disputes to which the clause referred or was intended.
affect, when said clause is not absolutist or open.

(ii) The arbitral tribunal is competent to decide whether the
The arbitral tribunal has been validly constituted. This is important.
for the purpose of making an award enforceable or not against a reluctant party or
absent from said arbitration. If the arbitral tribunal considers that it has
been properly summoned and which in turn is responsible for proposing
his means of defense and does not do so, it is the court itself that decides
declare her duly summoned and the court duly
constituted, pouring all the
relevant legal consequences.

However, the scope of this Kompetenz-Kompetenz principle,
especially in the second numeral specified above, it is
limited. In this regard, Article 16, paragraph 3 of the Model Law of
Uncitral, the Uncitral Rules for International Arbitration, as well as several
European legislation clearly establishes that on disputes of
competitions where it is alleged that a party did not validly subscribe to the
arbitration clause, that the subject matter of the dispute is not
arbitrable and/or is of public order, one of the parties is not able
to waive the ordinary jurisdiction of the courts under the
applicable law of interpretation, then in any of these cases and/or
In similar cases, the ordinary courts or tribunals will have jurisdiction.
the last word.

In conclusion, international jurisprudence and legislation are clear
when it comes to the validity of the arbitration clause itself,
establishing that the ordinary court or tribunal must refer to the court
arbitral, so that it may know of its own competence, unless the clause
arbitration is manifestly unlawful.12 Therefore, although the principle that
The matter at hand grants the arbitral tribunal the power to hear its

12 Article 1458 of the French Code of Civil Procedure.
Own competition, it is no less true that when it is
manifestly unlawful or void, the ordinary courts would be in full
capacity to know and rule on the matter, thus limiting the scope
of the aforementioned principle.

Guiding principles of the arbitration procedure

Arbitration agreements and arbitration itself are governed by principles
guidelines emanating from various model laws and regulations
international and the legislation of modern countries themselves.
Among these principles we can highlight:

Principle of autonomy.

As we have seen, international agreements, rules and regulations
internationally adopted models and international doctrine itself,
It provides for a separation between the agreement affected by a clause or
arbitration provision and the arbitration clause itself. Therefore, ultimately,
the invalidity of the contract itself, whether due to a defect of legal incapacity, a defect of
consent, lack of cause, price (when necessary for the
perfection of the Contract), etc. will not entail the nullity and/or not
This will invalidate the arbitration clause. Furthermore,
reputed non-existence of said contract, either because it was not
presented to the court, for being deemed null or for any other reason, no
should impact on the existence of an arbitration agreement if the
This, however, has been duly documented or provided.
However, there is no clear doctrinal position on whether this would be the
fate of the arbitration agreement when the Contract was never perfected, or was
flawed from its conception by what it could never have become
valid. An example of the latter would be when the object itself of the
The contract in question is manifestly illegal. Furthermore, it raises certain
Cases of termination by mutual agreement of a contract are intriguing. When
Even if it were a unilateral termination, it would not invalidate the agreement.
arbitral, especially when such unilateral decision is the very basis
of the controversy. However, what would happen when the
Settlement by mutual agreement? The doctrine does not maintain a position
clear in this regard. Some say it's reckless in the contractual relationship,
The arbitration agreement has ended, and on the other hand, other legal scholars believe that
during or after said contract (containing an arbitration agreement)
Any dispute that arises from issues that were agreed upon at the time
bringing to arbitration tribunals must be known by such without
exception.

Principle in favor of validity.

There is a marked pro-validity trend for arbitral awards and for the
arbitration proceedings. This trend is reflected in the wording of the
international codes and regulations on the subject, as well as in the
international position of the doctrinal scholars. This principle is shown,
mainly in two fundamental aspects13. First, there is a
presumption in favor of the validity of arbitral awards and second, there is
a limited scope of challenge or procedural review of awards in the
original jurisdictions, internationally.

13 González de Cassio, Francisco. Arbitration, first edition, Pomúa publishing house, Mexico,
DF, year 2004, p. 126

Principle of Strict Interpretation.

There is a principle of strict interpretation of arbitration clauses. If
The parties have agreed to enter into an arbitration agreement,
Therefore, this commitment must be assumed and interpreted in a
strict. An ordinary court and an arbitral tribunal itself must
Interpret that agreement with the utmost rigor. Otherwise,
Legal certainty and the very interpretation of the law would be at stake.
agreement of wills. It should be taken into account that if the parties have
I decide to submit their differences to arbitration; the party must be guaranteed
that he so requested, access to arbitration, since said
consent was already agreed upon with the other party at the time.

The legal scholar Gutierrez Brian postulates in his work “Arbitration Aspects
General”14 that arbitration entails 8 fundamental principles to
through which the arbitral institution has been discarding itself as
alternative method of conflict resolution.

14 HADERSPOCK Gutierrez Brian, Arbitration: General Aspects, Pages 10-14

Principle of Freedom

This implies the recognition of discretionary powers to the parties to
adopt alternative means to the judicial process for the resolution of their
controversies.

Principle of Flexibility

Both the arbitration process and procedure are characterized by being
irritual, in the sense that they can be adapted according to the
needs of the parties.

Privacy Principle

Private disputes are resolved through arbitration, and
The relationship between the parties and the arbitrators is also private, therefore the
The arbitration process and the final decision of the arbitrators remain confidential.
between the parties and the arbitral tribunal.

Principle of Suitability

When choosing the arbitrators, the parties can take into account the following:
knowledge of the arbitrators in the subject matter of the arbitration to receive
better judgment by the referees, thus ensuring the
quality of the ruling.

Principle of speed

It consists of the continuity of the procedures for solving the
controversies uninterruptedly, without obstacles or delays other than
we are used to witnessing in ordinary trials.

Principle of Equality

This principle falls within the realm of public order. This means that,
whether the dispute is submitted to ordinary proceedings or to arbitration, the
Equality cannot be ignored; it implies giving each party the same
opportunities to assert their rights by avoiding any kind of
impartiality thus ensuring the independence of the judge.

Principle of Hearing

It refers to the orality of alternative procedures. That is to say, the
The arbitration procedure is characterized by being oral, allowing a
more direct interaction between arbitrators and parties.

Principle of Contradiction

It consists of giving each litigant the opportunity for confrontation.
Among them. The ability to deny the other party's claims, to contradict the
allegations in such a way that both parties can defend themselves on equal terms
of conditions.

The Notification of the Lawsuit and the Defenses

The start of the arbitration process, in accordance with the provisions of the articles
Articles 25 and 27 of Law 489-0815, or, in other words, the beginning of the process itself of
arbitration occurs when the interested party notifies the claim to its
counterpart. In accordance with the aforementioned article 27, said claim
must 1) propose the arbitrators it considers, when applicable and 2) the
The defendant will have a period of fifteen (15) days to formulate his defense
and similarly propose their own arbitrator when applicable. Each party
has the right to appoint one (1) of the three (3) arbitrators available to the
Article 15 of this law to resolve ad hoc arbitrations. However, if
I will not name one of the parties to obstruct the process, he may
the appointment to a competent court is required, which is the court of
First Instance of the place of arbitration.

15 Law 489-08 on Commercial Arbitration.

It is important to note that said article states that said period may
extend further in accordance with the provisions of common law. No
However, this would be a good opportunity to question the legitimacy of said
expansion in the 21st century in a nation of just over 40,000
square kilometers.

Additionally, the law establishes in the aforementioned article 27 that the arbitrators
They must be designated within thirty (30) days after notification of the
demand. Although there is no deadline for submitting documents,
The law states that the arbitrators may set a time frame, a
gap, during which the parties must submit their respective
documentations.

Flaw and Rebellion

Article 29 deals with the lack of appearance and/or the defect in its sense
broader. It is almost indifferent in arbitration merits making a
differentiation between defect due to lack of appearance or due to lack of conclusion.
Basically, even if it were because the defendant had not responded in a
any claim, if it is because it has not appeared at the hearing, no
present evidence, but only if it has been duly
Once notified or summoned, the process will be considered adversarial. This is established.
clearly Article 29 of Law 489-08, without allowing the award to be
could be challenged for alleged violation of the right to a defense.
to say that the punishment, effective moreover, in arbitration matters of the defect and the
Rebellion is the reputation or presumption of contradictory nature of the process.

Testing Regulations

There is no fixed standard of proof in arbitration matters, regardless of the
subject matter and/or the value of the response. This is clearly stated in the
Article 30 of Law 489-08. This article establishes that arbitrators
They will be able to: “direct instruction in the manner they deem appropriate.”
It even gives them the power not only to admit but also to value, with complete freedom,
the evidence in question and/or its relevance to the answers in
litigation.

On the other hand, referees not only possess immense freedom when
to admit and assess evidence within the arbitration process; they also possess
an active role supported by law. The aforementioned article, in its paragraph 2,
It clearly states that at “any stage of the process” the arbitrators
They may request or order, as they deem appropriate, the clarifications and
measures they deem pertinent for the proper instruction of
process. The third number of said process is presented in a similar sense.
article, the same as what is known in the field of law
Commonly, it establishes that arbitrators are, in part, the owners of the process.
The inactivity of the parties or their lack of diligence does not prevent knowledge
and instruction of the process by the arbitrator. The arbitrator may decide
to finish the process and declare the debates closed as you see fit.
Even if there were procedural inactivity, according to their own criteria, the
The arbitrators may proceed to leave the case in a state of judgment and decide on the
same with the respective arbitration award.

Finally, in this sense, in accordance with the principle of immediacy,
Evidence other than documentary evidence must be presented in court and
before the full arbitration tribunal. However, in exceptional cases
or when the arbitrators so require, courts may be designated
ordinary procedures for holding the proceedings. This is specified in Article 32.
of Law 489-08. Judicial assistance may even be required in other cases.
nations by letters rogatory, so that said nations may be presented
evidence or such measures held in those jurisdictional forums or
foreign institutions.

On the other hand, the appointment of an expert may be suggested by the contribution
interested or ordered by the referee himself for the better instruction of
process. It is worth clarifying that the entire evidentiary regime in arbitration matters
It is in principle subject to what the parties have also agreed in
their moment. The parties in arbitration proceedings have the power to predetermine the
conditions under which an expert would have to be appointed. However,
As we have seen, the fact that the parties have specified as or to whom
The fact that an expert had to be appointed does not bind the arbitrator regarding the valuation of
such evidence or prevents him from ordering additional measures that even
possess the same nature as that previously agreed upon by the parties. That is to say,
Nothing prevents the arbitrators, after a pre-agreed arbitration, from, within the
active role that has been granted to him, they do not consider it pertinent to appoint a
supplementary expert report. Everything would be subject to the usefulness or relevance that
in the opinion of the arbitrators, the measure is appropriate.

Dispossession and Residual Competence

Just as ordinary courts are stripped of their powers by the ruling of a
In the judgment, the arbitration tribunals are stripped of their powers by the ruling of
arbitral award or subsequent supplementary arbitral awards.
Although in ordinary matters the courts decide a number of
exceptions and means of inadmissibility, that is, incidents in general, the
The final judgment is a single ruling on the main issue. Furthermore,
In arbitration matters, although there are provisional awards, it must also be
There must be a final arbitral award. As stipulated in Article 37 of the
Law 489-08, the arbitrators cease their functions with said final award,
in principle, or when there is a settlement agreement, uncontested withdrawal
of the plaintiff and their claims and/or the arbitrators understand that the
Knowledge of the case is now impossible or unnecessary.

In addition to the above, it should be clarified that it is said that “in principle” the
The arbitrators relinquish their power with the final award, as a responsibility falls upon them.
called residual competition. This residual competition, as it is called
Article 38 of the law states that within ten (10)
days after the notification of the award, which in turn must be carried out
Within five (5) days after its pronouncement16, it may
to request the arbitrators who issued said award 1) the correction by
typographical error, calculation error in the amounts, etc., or any similar reason,
of the award in question. 2) the clarification of a specific point or a
provision of the award and 3) the supplementation of the award on occasion to
motions formulated but not answered or resolved by the award
issued. Typographical, calculation or other similar errors may
to be remedied ex officio and without having heard the parties. The clarifications and
The complements must be pronounced after having heard them again.
parts and within ten (10) and twenty (20) days, respectively.

16 Article 6 Paragraph 7 of Law 489-08 on Commercial Arbitration.

CHAPTER IV: ARBITRATION PROCEDURE BEFORE THE CENTER OF
ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE RESOLUTION OF THE CHAMBER OF
TRADE AND PRODUCTION OF SANTO DOMINGO.

Alternative Dispute Resolution Center

Law 50-87, dated June 4, 1987, on Official Chambers of
Trade and Production of the Republic, as amended by Law 181-09
empowers the Chambers of Commerce and Production to establish in their
respective jurisdictions, an Alternative Dispute Resolution Center
Controversies, with legal personality.

Alternative Dispute Resolution Centers are dedicated to
resolve disputes that arise between two or more natural persons or
legal entities, whether members of the Chambers or not, that have agreed to submit the
resolution of the same to methods and regulations of the Chamber of which it
try.

These Centers may institute within their jurisdiction all Methods of
Alternative Solution that you deem relevant, including but not limited to
to arbitration, amicable settlement, conciliation and mediation.
They can also be aware of all types of controversy that may be subject to
transaction, including those in which the State is a party or
any of its dependencies.

The Center for Alternative Dispute Resolution, hereinafter CRC,
It is managed by a Management Firm elected by the Board of Directors of the
corresponding Chamber of Commerce, which is composed of a
maximum of 15 members, who once elected will modify their
composition every 2 years by selecting 3 new members.

Any member of the CRC's Board of Directors who has a direct interest or
indirect party in a dispute submitted to arbitration will be disqualified
to participate in the deliberations and decisions that are adopted in
relationship with them.

The Center for Alternative Dispute Resolution, in compliance with
the provisions of Article 4 of the Regulations of the Conciliation Council
and Arbitration of the Santo Domingo Chamber of Commerce and Production,
It currently has three secretaries who are also in charge
from the Legal Department of the Chamber of Commerce and Production of Santo
On Sunday, they are in charge of managing the entire arbitration process and it is
who is responsible for coordinating all the functions of the law firm
Manager, under his instructions.

Current Legal Framework

The current legal framework in the institutional arbitration procedure before the
The Alternative Dispute Resolution Center is as follows:

Law 489-08 of December 19, 2008, repeals articles
Articles 1003 et seq. of the Code of Civil Procedure in force in the
Dominican Republic.

Law 50-87, dated June 4, 1987, on Official Chambers of
Trade and Production of the Republic, modified by Law 181-
09.

Regulations of the Conciliation and Arbitration Council of the Chamber of
Trade and Production of Santo Domingo.

Internal Procedure Regulations of the Chamber of Commerce and
Production from Santo Domingo.

Regulations for Conciliation and Mediation.

Guidelines for Arbitrators of the Conciliation and Arbitration Council
of the Chamber of Commerce and Production of Santo Domingo.

. Code of Ethics for Referees.

Arbitration proceedings before the Alternative Dispute Resolution Center
Controversies

Article 5 of the Regulations of the Conciliation and Arbitration Council of the
The Santo Domingo Chamber of Commerce and Production stipulates that all
written notice or notification submitted by the parties, as well as any
five copies of the attached document must be deposited in accordance with the
number of referees plus an additional duplicate for the Secretariat of
CRC Management Office and an additional one for the other party.

The aforementioned Regulation, in its article 6, provides that all time limits
established therein and those that are set during the course of the process are
francs, except in cases where the Arbitral Tribunal has expressly
established otherwise.

Arbitration Claim

Article 7 of the Regulations of the Conciliation and Arbitration Council of the
The Chamber of Commerce and Production of Santo Domingo stipulates that the part
If a party resorts to arbitration, they must notify the defendant of their claim.
together with its attached documents and then to the Secretariat of the
CRC Management Office.

The complaint must contain:

It must be done by means of a bailiff's act.

. Full general information of the parties and their representatives, if any.
has and the address to which the documents must be served and
documents required during the process.

Description of the nature and circumstances of the controversy,
origin of the demand.

. Indication of the claims including the amounts claimed, if
there would be

Convention where the arbitration clause is included in the document of
commitment that underpins the competence of the Arbitral Tribunal,
as well as documents and information that clearly establish
the circumstances of the case.

. Request for integration of the arbitral tribunal, indicating the name of
three referees in order of preference.

The plaintiff must, in order to comply with the provisions
of Article 2 of the Internal Procedure Regulations of the Chamber of
Trade and Production of Santo Domingo, at the time of notifying the
Secretariat of the CRC's Board of Directors, a payment of RD$ 50,000.00 no
reimbursable as an advance payment of the sum corresponding to the
administrative fee, which is paid by means of a certified check
Name of the Chamber of Commerce and Production of Santo Domingo.

Article 7 of the Regulations of the Conciliation and Arbitration Council of the
The Santo Domingo Chamber of Commerce and Production states that if the
the plaintiff does not meet the requirement established above of
make the advance payment of the fee amount
In administrative matters, the secretariat will set a deadline of 15 days for it to proceed to
its fulfillment and upon expiration of said term, the file will be
archived without prejudice to the plaintiff's right to present
again their demand.
As provided in Article 3 of the Internal Procedure Regulations of the
Santo Domingo Chamber of Commerce and Production, after receiving the
demand and verify that it complies with the provisions of the Regulation,
The CRC secretariat will calculate the administrative expenses and
arbitration fees for the process, and will submit them for approval
corresponding to the Treasurer of the CRC's Board of Directors.

Then, in accordance with the provisions of Article 4 of the same Regulation,
The CRC Secretariat will proceed to send a copy to the defendant.
of the file with a copy of the list of Referees, as well as a
a copy of the Regulations, and with a communication reminding
that within 15 days from the notification made by the
The plaintiff must file their written defense and complaint
reconventional.

Defense and Counterclaim

Article 8 of the Regulations of the Conciliation and Arbitration Council of the
The Chamber of Commerce and Production of Santo Domingo stipulates that the part
The defendant will respond within 15 days from the date
receipt of the claim, through a written defense, in which it must
to rule on the claims of the defendant.

The defendant's written defense must be served on the
secretary of the CRC's Board of Directors, and must also contain:

. Full general information of the parties and their representatives, if any.
has the address where the documents should be served and
documents required during the process.

. Their position on the claims of the plaintiff.

. His arguments and comments on the origin of the lawsuit;

The indication of the names of three referees in order of
preference and their observations and comments on the referees of
the plaintiff, if any.

The Secretariat may grant an additional period for the deposit of the document.
defense, in case the defendant requests it by
communication justifying the impossibility of complying with this
Formalities must be met within the established timeframe. This timeframe cannot exceed [the specified period].
within 15 days and will only be granted once.

If the defendant wishes to file a counterclaim, the
will be submitted together with its written response to the lawsuit
original. The counterclaim must be served successively
to the counterclaim defendant and the Secretary of the CRC.

The counterclaim will contain:

A detailed account of the events that gave rise to the
counterclaim.

. Indication of the claims including the amounts claimed, if
if there were any;

The main defendant will have a period of 15 days counted from
from the notification of this counterclaim, to notify your
written response to the counterclaimant and the Secretariat of
CRC Management Office, being able to exceptionally request a period
to present their resources and deposit documents no more than 15 days in advance,
provided that the extension request contains the comments of the
demanded in relation to the number of arbitrators and their selection.

Rebellion

Article 10 of the Regulations of the Conciliation and Arbitration Council of the
The Santo Domingo Chamber of Commerce and Production stipulates that if in the
the period established in Article 8 of these Regulations, or that granted by
The Secretary, one of the parties has not notified the other party of its writing or
simply refuses or abstains from participating in arbitration in any
At this stage, the process will continue.

If within 15 days of notification of the claim, the party
If the defendant does not respond, a communication will be sent to him/her stating that
informs that, pursuant to Article 10.2 of the Arbitration Rules,
The arbitration process will continue in his absence, and will be deemed to be the same.
as contradictory.

That is, if one of the parties, duly notified, does not appear, the
The Arbitral Tribunal may continue the arbitration process, the
same as contradictory.

Arbitral tribunal

The Kompetenz-Kompetenz principle is manifested in the procedure
arbitration before the Center for Alternative Dispute Resolution.
Article 11 of the Regulations of the Conciliation and Arbitration Council of the
The Chamber of Commerce and Production of Santo Domingo stipulates that the
The arbitral tribunal is the only one with the authority to decide on its own
competitors

The exception of lack of jurisdiction or the objection to arbitration due to non-existence,
nullity or expiry of an arbitration clause or commitment document
or for any other reason must be stated at the beginning of the litigation under penalty of
of inadmissibility.

Referees

Article 12 of the Regulations of the Conciliation and Arbitration Council of the
The Santo Domingo Chamber of Commerce and Production stipulates that the CRC
It will have an Official List of Referees made up of professionals from
various disciplines that, upon prior recommendation of the Management Firm,
It must be approved by the Board of Directors of the Chamber of Commerce and
Production from Santo Domingo. This will be validated annually by the CRC.
recommending appointments and exclusions of members.

When the parties have not agreed on the number of
The Board of Directors will determine the arbitrators.

The Regulations of the Conciliation and Arbitration Council of the Chamber of
The Trade and Production Committee of Santo Domingo stipulates that within a period of 15
days from the moment the Secretariat receives the Defense Statement
The Management Firm will form the Arbitration Tribunal with the first arbitrator of
the list proposed by the claimant, the first arbitrator on the list
proposed by the defendant and will randomly choose the arbitrator who will preside
the Arbitration Tribunal.

The CRC's Board of Directors, as established in Article 15 of
Regulations of the Conciliation and Arbitration Council of the Chamber of
The Santo Domingo Trade and Production Commission will inform the
arbitrators on their appointment, within 3 days following their
election. Similarly, the Steering Committee will notify the parties about
the agreed appointment.

As provided for in Article 16 of the Council Regulations
Conciliation and Arbitration of the Santo Chamber of Commerce and Production
On Sunday, the referees must accept their roles within 15 days.
from the date on which they have received notification of their
appointment. The referee must, upon acceptance, sign a
Declaration of Independence, Impartiality and Confidentiality, as well as
declare their willingness to comply with the provisions of Article 12.4 of
this Regulation.

The Internal Procedure Regulations of the Chamber of Commerce and
Santo Domingo Production establishes that once the
The Arbitration Tribunal Secretariat will proceed to calculate the Administrative Fee
and Arbitration Fees, according to the amount established in the instance
initial claim of the main claim and the counterclaim, in the
applicable cases and will refer them to the Treasurer of the managing firm for their
approval.

challenge

The Regulations of the Conciliation and Arbitration Council of the Chamber of
The Trade and Production Committee of Santo Domingo enables recusal in the
cases in which there are circumstances that give rise to justifiable doubts in
the decision of the dispute submitted to arbitration.

The recusal must be notified to the CRC's Board of Directors and the other
party, as well as the arbitrator who is proposed to be challenged and the other arbitrators
that make up the Arbitration Tribunal, indicating the reasons that justify the
recusal, within 15 days from the date on which it has been
informed about the appointment of the arbitrator subject to challenge.

The CRC's Board of Directors will be informed and will make a final decision within the
the shortest possible timeframe for challenging any arbitrator.

After the Mission Act has been signed, the referee may only be challenged by
reasons arising after the date indicated in said documents.

It is important to note that in practice it is quite difficult for this to be
The challenge of an arbitrator was granted, since the CRC's Board of Directors,
In the absence of local standardization, it is using the following criteria
to evaluate requests for the recusal of arbitrators a manual called
“IBA Guidelines on Conflicts of Interest in Arbitration
International”, approved by the Council of the International Bar
Association on May 22, 2004, which in no way corresponds to the
needs of the Dominican Republic.

This Guidelines Manual classifies the circumstances that do or do not create a
conflict of interest as follows:

. Red List:

It consists of two parts: the Non-waivable Red List and the Red List
Waiver. These Lists contain a non-exhaustive list of
specific situations likely to create doubts about the
impartiality and independence of the referee, as the case may be.

The Non-Waiverable Red List includes situations that arise as
This is a consequence of the principle that no one can be both judge and party at the same time.
Therefore, revealing the facts or circumstances of the case will not prevent the
conflict of interest.

The Waivable Red List includes serious situations, but not so serious ones.
Given its seriousness, it will only be considered waivable if the
parties, in accordance with the General Rule and aware of the conflict of
interests express their will that the person they have chosen
perform the functions of an arbitrator.

. Orange List:

It is a non-exhaustive statement of specific situations (which
(depending on the facts or particular circumstances of the case), to
the perspectives of the parties involved could create doubts about impartiality or
referee independence. The Orange List reflects situations where
It is up to the referee to make them known.

In all these cases it is understood that the parties accept the arbitrator if,
Having revealed the relevant facts or circumstances,
The parties do not exercise their right to object to the arbitrator within the deadline
established for that purpose.

. Green List:

Contains a non-exhaustive list of specific situations that,
From an objective point of view, they are not capable of creating, nor do they create, a
conflict of interest. Therefore, the arbitrator has no duty to disclose the
situations covered by the Green List.

Collection from the Parties.

Article 9 of the Internal Rules of Procedure of the Chamber of
The Trade and Production Committee of Santo Domingo stipulates that once they have been
The fees having been set by the appointed Arbitration Tribunal, the Secretariat
will send the corresponding invoice to the parties.

If 15 days elapse after the repeated payment,
without either party having made the payment and the Secretariat not
If a reasoned request for an extension has been received, the company will proceed to communicate
to the parties that the CRC has decided on the formal dispossession of the
Arbitral jurisdiction.

The secretariat may only grant a reasoned request for an extension, because
a period that will never exceed 15 days.

In the event that the defendant refuses to pay the expenses and
The fees that are due to him/her are owed to the plaintiff.
It is appropriate to cover them. In this case, a new one may be granted.
a period of 15 days counted from the date of expiry of the term
given to the defendant.

The graph below, relating to the Costs of
The procedure has been taken from a presentation made by the
Alternative Dispute Resolution Center of the Chamber of
Trade and Production of Santo Domingo.

CRC Arbitration Rules Proceeding Costs Fee
Administrative Fees
Arbitration RD $50,000.00 Deductible Advance
paid by the
Plaintiff Party
Demanding
50 %
Part of it
Defendant
50 %

Delivery of the File to the Court

In compliance with the provisions of Article 19 of the Regulation of
Conciliation and Arbitration Council of the Chamber of Commerce and
Santo Domingo Production, the CRC's Board of Directors will empower
through the Secretariat to the Arbitration Tribunal of the Case, always and
when the parties have deposited the full amount of the provision for expenses and
of the arbitrators' fees required by the Secretariat.

Once the Arbitration Tribunal has been appointed, the Secretariat of the Management Firm
The CRC will notify the parties of the location where the proceedings will take place.
arbitral.

Rules Applicable to the Procedure and the Fund.

The Arbitral Tribunal will apply the procedural rules and the rules of law.
by which the arbitrators will conduct and decide the process, in accordance with the
Law chosen by the parties.

The Arbitration Tribunal shall be governed by the stipulations of the contract, if the
where there are, and subsidiarily by the customs of commerce that are applicable to
unless the parties indicate otherwise in the arbitration clause or the
commitment. In the event that they have been authorized to act as
friendly mediators will be able to decide equitably.

Mission Record

Article 23 of the Regulations of the Conciliation and Arbitration Council of the
The Santo Domingo Chamber of Commerce and Production stipulates that in a
a period of 30 days from the moment the file is delivered to
The Arbitration Tribunal must send a record to the CRC secretariat that
Please specify your mission, based on the documents provided by the
parties. The Arbitral Tribunal may request a reasoned extension of the deadline
previously cited.

The Mission Statement must contain the following statements:

. Full general information of the parties and their representatives, if applicable.
any, and the arbitrators.

Choice of domicile for the purpose of validly carrying out all
notifications or send all communications during the
arbitration process.

Summary statement of the parties' claims.

Determination of the litigious issues to be resolved.

. Seat of arbitration.

Applicable procedural rules.

Rules of law to be applied or express mention that the
Arbitrators may act as friendly mediators by judging
in accordance with equity.

If one of the parties refuses to participate in the drafting of said minutes,
The CRC's Board of Directors will verify its regularity and
will grant that party a deadline for its signature. Upon expiration of this deadline
The arbitration proceedings will continue and the award may be issued.

The Internal Procedure Regulations of the Chamber of Commerce and
The Santo Domingo Production Law, in its article 12, stipulates that after
The Court deposits the Mission Act with the Secretariat, the latter will then
will be sent to the parties, so that they can make the appropriate considerations, in a
15-day period.

Once that deadline for the parties' observations on the Mission Act has expired,
The meeting will then be convened for the signing of the agreement. Once signed
The Mission Act, signed by the parties, will be certified by the Secretariat and
subsequently sent to the members of the Arbitration Tribunal and the parties.

The secretariat will proceed with the payment of the first 50% corresponding to the
fees, withholding the 10% corresponding to the Income Tax
Pension.

Article 15 of the Internal Rules of Procedure of the Chamber of
The Trade and Production Committee of Santo Domingo states that once signed
The Mission Act, the Arbitration Tribunal will define the work schedule,
establishing the calendar date for the hearings to be held within the
conducting the process, which may not exceed a number of 4 in
consecutive order. Any changes to the schedule must be
notified to the Secretariat and the parties.

New Demands

Pursuant to Article 24 of the Council Regulation
Conciliation and Arbitration of the Santo Chamber of Commerce and Production
On Sunday, neither party may make new claims or
introduce new claims, principal or counterclaims, different
of those stipulated in the Mission Statement once it is approved and signed
is.

Investigation of the Case

As provided by the Regulations of the Council of Conciliation and Arbitration of
the Santo Domingo Chamber of Commerce and Production, the Court
The arbitral tribunal must expedite the investigation, using the means available to it.
considers appropriate.

Testing

Each party will bear the burden of proof regarding the facts that
justify their claim or defense. The Arbitration Tribunal may request
the documents and evidence that will be presented by said party in support
of their claims.

This court plays an active role in the assessment of the evidence,
These may determine the admissibility, relevance and foundation
in accordance with his intimate conviction.

Hearings

In the event of hearings, the Secretariat of the Managing Office of
CRC will notify the parties within a period of no less than 10 days.
advance notice, the date, time and place where it will take place.

In the event that a witness hearing is scheduled, each of the parties
must inform the Arbitration Tribunal and the other party of the general information of
witnesses and reasons for their appearance, 5 days before the hearing.

Conservative and Provisional Measures

Article 31 of the Regulations of the Conciliation and Arbitration Council of the
The Santo Domingo Chamber of Commerce and Production states that
The Arbitral Tribunal may, at the request of either party, adopt
any protective measure, including the preservation of assets that
form part of said object, such as its deposit in the hands of a
Third, the appointment of a guardian or the sale of perishable goods.

These measures may be ordered in a Provisional Award and may be
subject to the deposit of a bond.

Closing of the Instruction

The Arbitration Tribunal may declare the debates closed once
consider yourself sufficiently edified in the aspects relating to the
controversy. Once the debates are declared closed, the Arbitration Tribunal
You must notify the secretary.

The reopening of the debates may be ordered either ex officio or at the request of the court.
request of one of the parties, by the Arbitral Tribunal, in the event that
this he considers necessary.

Charts on statistics from the Alternative Dispute Resolution Center
Controversies of the Chamber of Commerce and Saint Production
Sunday.

The following statistical graphs have been taken from a presentation
conducted by the Center for Alternative Dispute Resolution of the
Santo Domingo Chamber of Commerce and Production.

Administration of Arbitration Processes Statistics Cases
2009 – 2011

Administration of Arbitration Processes

Arbitration Matters 2009-2011
Distribution of Arbitration Cases by Economic SectorTelecommunications19%
Construction34%
Electric 13%
Corporate13%
Computer Science/Technology6%
Graphic Design3%
Services
6%
Rent6%
TelecommunicationsConstructionElectricalCorporateIT/TechnologyGraphic DesignServices
Rent

CHAPTER V: THE ARBITRAL AWARD. NATURE, EFFECTS AND
CHALLENGE.

The arbitral award. Nature, effects and challenge

Court awards and judgments

The final decision issued by the arbitration award is called an arbitration award.
arbitrators regarding the disputed issues in the arbitration clause or
the commitment.17

17 Arias Arzeno, Samuel et al. In: Alternative Dispute Resolution, first edition.
National School of the Judiciary, Santo Domingo, Dominican Republic, 2002, p.
367.

In the case of arbitration under law, the award, which is a kind of
The sentence must conform to the legal norms applicable to the species; in
Otherwise, it should be a court of amicable mediators.
It must be rendered outside the bounds of legality and based on equity, which
Many doctrinaires have called it “knowledge and understanding.”18

18 Ditto.

19 González de Cossio, Francisco. Arbitration, first edition, Porrúa publishing house, Mexico,
DF, year 2004, p. 380

According to the most recent international trends, it was a
decision of an arbitral tribunal that decides definitively on all or
part of the substance of a controversy or on a procedural issue that
has the result of ending the arbitration proceedings or that contemplates
a transaction entered into between the parties, issued within the environment of
an arbitration linked to a state legal order, in principle that of the
seat of arbitration.19

Law 50-87, on Official Chambers of Commerce and Production, dated
June 4, 1987, gives the following definition: “Decision issued by
arbitral tribunal regarding the disputes submitted to its consideration.”

The most notable difference between an arbitral award and a court judgment,
It lies in the fact that in the first one, jurisdiction and competence are given to the
arbitrators as a consequence of the autonomy of the will of the parties
embodied in a contract (arbitration clause); and in the case of judgments
judicial decisions are issued by a court to which the law
depending on the subject matter, it grants it the competence to
to hear certain disputes, that is, it is a jurisdictional act
because it emanates from a judicial official. Furthermore, in the case of the award,
Both parties agree on who will resolve the dispute, in the
In the event that a legal issue arises, however, in the judicial sphere, a party that
The lawsuit compels the other party to defend themselves in court.
finding out which one it is at the time of notification.
Regarding their implementation, there are several differences, since
the arbitral decision, depending on the procedure in question, if it is Ad-
Hoc or Institutional have different execution mechanisms, in the first
In this case, the award must be authorized by the court of first instance.
competent (Art. 41 Law 489-08, on Commercial Arbitration); but in the case
from the institutional, are not subject to any validity, Law 181-09, which
amends Law 50-87, on Official Chambers of Commerce and Production,
It states in its 17, paragraph II and II, that they are not subject to the procedure
of article 41 of the aforementioned Law 489-08 and that are definitive and not
subject to any recourse. Respecting in both cases the action in
nullity and the means of challenging it.

As for judicial decisions, they are subject to res judicata.
except in the case of provisional execution, following the procedures
established by law.

Nature of the award: finality at origin

The arbitral award has been conceived as a final decision and
binding, adopted by arbitration courts, which puts an end to all
or some of the existing differences between the parties, a situation that I could
to cover the substance of the matter, the competence of the arbitrators, or some aspect
procedural involving the termination of the process20.

20 Tolero Rueda, Santiago. International Commercial Arbitration, Temis Publishing House, Bogotá
Colombia, 2008, p. 358.

21 Ibid. p. 357.

When parties resort to arbitration, they hope to resolve their
disputes in a definitive and binding manner. The award is the document
procedural that meets this expectation.21

The final decisions of the arbitrators constitute awards. This
An approach to the notion of an arbitral award mainly generates two
effects. On the one hand, awards are the only pronouncements that
are subject to recognition and enforcement in commercial arbitration
international and, on the other hand, there is a general principle, according to which,
The success of challenging an award depends, to a large extent, on whether
the interested party would have raised their respective objection before the
arbitral tribunal and at the appropriate procedural moment.22

22 Ibid.

23 Article 41 Law 489-08, on Commercial Arbitration.

24 Article 17, paragraph II.

25 In our country, matters relating to competition are addressed in Article 20 of Law 489-
08 and 41 of Law 50-87.

In our country, the finality of the award may depend on the procedure
in question. In the case of ad hoc arbitration, its validity will depend on the
approval by the competent court23. However, in the case
From the Institutional Law, Law 181-09, establishes that after its issuance
They have the same enforceability as a second-instance judgment.24

Types of Awards

According to the classification of international doctrine, the following exist:
types of awards:

Award on jurisdiction

It is the award in which the arbitral tribunal admits or rejects its jurisdiction.
Arbitration laws allow the arbitrator to decide by separate award
about their competence.25

Incidental award

It is an interim decision that takes place during the procedure and without
put an end to it.

Partial award

It is the one that deals with an object of the litigation; that is, with one of the
points of the claim or the response and has firmness on said
appearance.

Final award

It is the award that decides on all the claims submitted by the
parties and that, consequently, puts an end to the arbitration proceedings.

Default judgment26
26 In our legal system this is equivalent to the defect described in Article 57 of the Law
50-87; to the lack of appearance of Law 489-08 and to the rebellion, of the Regulation of
CCA, art. 10.

27 Article 69 Law 50-87; 35 of Law 489-08 and 34 of the CCA Regulations

It is one in which one of the parties refuses to participate in the
procedure and the arbitral tribunal finds itself needing to proceed without
the active participation of the rebellious party.

. Award agreed upon27

Its purpose is to elevate to an award a transaction in which the parties involved
the parties. The reason is to provide an enforceable title to the agreement.

In our legislation, another type can also be observed, which is the arbitration award.
provisional, which deals with precautionary measures and the suspension or
lifting of the same. (Articles 20.1, 20.2 and 13 of Law 489-08 and
16, paragraph VII and VII of Law 181-09).

Ruling of the Award

According to Article 33 of Law 489-08, the rules applicable to the fund of
disputes will depend on whether it is an equity-based arbitration or
amicable mediator, if the parties have so agreed; if it concerns
international arbitration that will be subject to the rules chosen by the
parties in accordance with the State concerned; in the event that the parties do not
Indicate the applicable legal rules; the arbitral tribunal will apply the
that it deems appropriate. In all cases, the court shall take into account
It takes into account the stipulations of the contract, and will consider the customs
applicable.

In both ad hoc and institutional arbitration, in the event that
If there is more than one referee, the decisions will be made secretly and by
majority vote. In the first of these, the parties may stipulate another
thing.28

28See article 34 of Law 489-08 and 61 of Law 50-87.

Similarly, if there is no majority or in case of a tie, it will be in the
that the president attends.

If an agreement occurs during the knowledge of the procedure
transactional, whether concerning a part or the entire dispute, the
The court will terminate part or all of the litigation. This agreement may
to be carried out in the form of an award, if both parties so request and if the court
finds no necessary reason to oppose. In the event that a ruling is issued
This type of award will have the same force as one on the merits.

Time limit, form, content and notification of the award

Regarding the time limits for issuing awards, there are certain
Differences between ad hoc and institutional arbitration. Law 489-2008, no.
It stipulates a deadline for issuing the award, since the parties are the ones who
They choose how the procedure will be carried out. In the Institutional setting, however, the
Law 50-87 stipulates that it must be issued within a period of 1 month counted
from the close of the debates, but could be extended for reasons
justified with prior authorization from the Board of Directors of the Council
Conciliation and Arbitration.

With regard to the form and content of the award, both procedures
They are similar in that they require that it be done in writing, the names of the
arbitrators, the general terms of the parties and their representatives, their
conclusions, the summary exposition of the points of fact and law,
the motivations (in the case of Ad-hoc the parties may stipulate the
On the contrary), the grounds and the device. Also, the date and place where
It was dictated. The signatures of all referees are required. In the event that
If one refuses to sign it, it will be recorded and the decision will have the same effect.
It is valid as if it had been signed by everyone. They are also allowed
make dissenting or reasoned votes.

The costs of the proceedings, in the case of ad hoc arbitration, prior
the parties' agreement, the arbitrators decide on these, which include the
fees and expenses of the referees, and where applicable, those of the
parties and their representatives. Likewise, that of the managing entity
of the procedure and other expenses incurred therein. In the
made before the Chamber of Commerce and Production (Institutional), are set
the costs, such as administrative fees, individual fees for each
referee, travel expenses, expenses incurred by the referees; amount of the
expert advice or any other type of assistance required by the
referees; travel expenses and outlays incurred by witnesses.
amount of expenses and fees for representation and
assistance of lawyers or persons appointed by the winning party,
will be borne by the losing party only to the extent that the
The Arbitration Tribunal decides that the amount of the same is reasonable.
Furthermore, the Arbitral Tribunal may order compensation for said
Costs between the parties29. On the arbitrators' fees and the rate
There are special administrative rates, which may vary by state.
CCA Management Office.

29 Article 70 Law 50-87.

The time limit for notifying awards varies depending on the procedure followed.
In the case of Ad-hoc, the parties will stipulate the form and the term, and in
If no date is specified, it will be done within 5 days from its
pronouncement. In the institutional context, the presiding referee must
deposit the award in the Secretariat of the CCA's Board of Directors within 3 days
of dictation. Subsequently, the secretariat will proceed to notify copies
certified to the parties within 5 days of receipt.

Homologation or exequatur: a graceful procedure

The arbitration process comes to an end with the issuance of the final award.
The referees' mission is completed and their jurisdiction ceases. The decision of
The referees disempower them, but where their task ends, in some
cases opens the possibility for courts to act to establish their
validity and authorize its execution.

According to the generally accepted mechanism in the various
arbitration regulations, the arbitrator and the judge exchange primacy according to
the moment in the arbitration in which they are located. In the conduct of the process
And until the award is issued, the arbitrators are the absolute protagonists,
relegating judges to sporadic and very restricted interventions.
But from the issuance of the award until its final execution, it is the
judiciary who arrogates to themselves the monopoly of action, declaring, in accordance
to strict parameters, the validity and effectiveness of the award.

In the pre-award phase, judicial abstention is the rule and
intervention is the exception.

Due to its private nature, the award only has effect between the parties, and has a
merely declarative and non-enforceable in nature. Its true effectiveness is
materializes with its integration into the corresponding legal system,
through judicial recognition which in turn enables its subsequent
execution, in the manner provided for court judgments
ordinary.

When the award recognition phase is reached, this decision
judicial eliminates the differences between these and judicial decisions.

In comparative law, there are various ways in which the
courts to ratify arbitral awards. In many systems30,
including ours, such a request is eminently gracious or
administrative. That is to say, there are no debates or contradictions. The part
The applicant only needs to submit the required documents along with their request.

30 Among the legal systems that adopted this solution is the Dominican one, in
its article 44. Also the French one (articles 1477 and 1478 of the New Code of
Civil Procedure) and Italian (Article 825 of the Code of Civil Procedure). The law
Spanish Civil Procedure also establishes a graceful procedure for the
enforcement of arbitral awards
relevant, and the judge is limited to verifying whether one of the following does not exist
reasons for denial.

Although the judge in the recognition case has very limited powers to
To analyze the award submitted to him, in the Dominican sphere there is the
possibility of obtaining provisional suspension -before the judge of the
Referrals of the award when there is a pending annulment action.

The procedure established by Dominican legislation for the
The recognition of arbitral awards is described in the Law
489-08, on Commercial Arbitration. This is because it is only necessary in
Ad-hoc arbitration. Articles 41 et seq. stipulate that it must
to be carried out before the court of first instance of the place where it is deemed
dictated. In the case of an award to be enforced abroad, the
Procedural rules and international treaties will determine the
jurisdiction. When dealing with awards issued outside the country, the
The competent court to grant exequatur is the Civil and Commercial Chamber
from the Court of First Instance of the National District, this grants him
enforceable force throughout the national territory. The requesting party must
deposit the original award and the agreement or contract that stipulates it in the
court. Decisions granting recognition and exequatur will be
known in non-contentious jurisdiction, by court order.

The non-appealability of arbitral awards: direct action in
nullity

Resources are fundamental elements of procedural law
any country. Through them, the parties express their disagreement with
the decision regarding their conflict, always based on arguments from
right.

Additionally, the resources serve the public interest, insofar as
They allow hierarchical control of the actions of the judiciary, under a
pyramid scheme of competencies that outlines the natural progression of
judgments towards the authority of res irrevocably judged.
Regardless of your specific mission from your character
ordinary or extraordinary, as well as their effects on the parties, the
resources aim to maintain a certain consistency in the judicial activity of
State.

In arbitration, the essence and even the justification of the resources changes
due to its private nature, but fundamentally because of the
the speed inherent in the method and the definitive nature of its solution. Even,
A substantial advantage of arbitration is the possibility of
to evade the judicial appeals system.

Undoubtedly, the parties that resort to arbitration seek a quick solution
and definitively resolve their litigation outside of state courts, which may
be incompatible with the exercise of the resources of the process
judicial. This consideration, coupled with the relativity of the effects of the award,
It causes the legislator to restrict access to avenues of redress against the
arbitration and narrow the channels for attacking it.31

31 According to Julio Bennetti, “those who resort to arbitration waive their right to assert their rights
rights before the judges of the State, because they want a quick solution that would not be
with the use of ordinary resources” (Benneti, Julio, cited by Monroy Cabra,
Marco Gerardo, Appeals against the arbitration award, work included in The Contract of
Arbitration, compilation coordinated by Silva Romero, Eduardo, and Mantilla Espinosa,
Fabricio, Editorial Legis, Bogotá, 2005, page 671).

The above arguments are not intended to advocate for a
total prohibition of appeals against the award. The establishment of a
A minimum oversight mechanism is healthy, first of all understanding,
the human condition of referees and the consequent possibility of error
underlying that condition. Arbitration being a jurisdictional process
which affects rights and obligations, it is logical that formulas are foreseen
to correct any errors that the award may contain.

It should not be forgotten that, in principle, the parties have decided to remove the
knowledge of their dispute over state jurisdiction, and that this is the
The main motive for arbitration. Therefore, the exercise of remedies against the
The award must respect the exclusive effect of the arbitration agreement. If it is allowed to
the courts to re-examine the matter submitted to arbitration on appeal,
The mechanism is stripped of its fundamental objective as a method
alternative justice.

In light of the above, most legislations have recognized
strict and very special remedies against the award, the action for
Excellence is annulment. It is also the only recourse contemplated in the
UNCITRAL Model Law, on which our Law 489-08 is based
country.

In comparative law there are two schools of thought on whether it is a
The second meaning is: a recourse or action relating to nullity.
the most accurate, because the court cannot evaluate the aspects of
substance, but is limited to verifying the existence of a cause of nullity.

Finally, it is important to establish that in our current reality,
This is the only way to challenge an award.
arbitration. Except for arbitration proceedings prior to the latest
legislative amendments.

Nature of the action for annulment, time limit and jurisdiction

Law 489-08 introduces, for the first time in our country, the action in
nullity, against arbitral awards, in its articles 20 numeral 3, 21
numerals 2 and 39. Similarly, Law 181-09 contemplates this action in
its article 17.

The first of these, consecrates its application to all the awards issued
on the occasion of ad-hoc or institutional arbitrations, national or
international, carried out in Dominican territory or outside of it, without
without prejudice to the provisions of international treaties in which the
the Dominican State is a party, or in special laws on arbitration, as
This is the case of the aforementioned Law 181-09.

The justification for the action for annulment lies, on the one hand, in the
Mixed nature of arbitration: it arises from a contract (clause or
arbitration agreement) and ends with an award endowed with effects
properly jurisdictional: res judicata and enforceability (Article 36.1 and
40.2 of Law 489-08 and 17 of Law 181-09).

The author José González-Montes says, in the work Judicial Intervention in
Arbitration, which “Precisely, if the legal system endows the award
arbitral effects mentioned, there is no doubt that some type of control
judicial must be arbitrated.”

For this reason, it must be understood that no agreement or regulation of
arbitration may involve or result in the parties waiving their right
fundamental right to effective judicial protection.

Our country's Commercial Arbitration Law confuses the terms of
action and resource, but it should be understood as a main action, since
In this case, the court does not examine the facts or the application of the law, nor
assesses or evaluates the evidence, limiting itself to monitoring regularity
material or procedural aspects of the award or arbitration or, in any case, the
performance in procendo of the referees.

The voidable awards are the incidental, provincial, partial and
bottom.

Reasons for annulment

The grounds that may give rise to an action for annulment are found
stated in article 39, paragraph 2 of Law 489-08 and 17 paragraph 3 of
Law 181-09.

Article 39, paragraph 2:

  1. a) That one of the parties to the arbitration agreement referred to in the
    Article 10 was affected by some disability, or that said
    the agreement is not valid under the law to which the parties have agreed.
    submitted, or if nothing has been indicated in this regard, by virtue of
    Dominican law.

  1. b) That there has been a failure to observe due process, that it has
    translated into a violation of the right to defense.

  1. c) That the award relates to a dispute not foreseen in the agreement of
    arbitration or contains decisions that exceed the terms of the agreement
    of arbitration. However, if the provisions of the award that are
    They refer to the issues submitted to arbitration and can be separated from
    those that are not, only the latter may be cancelled.
  2. d) That the composition of the arbitral tribunal or the arbitral procedure does not
    have complied with the agreement between the parties, unless said agreement
    was in conflict with a provision of this law, of which the
    parties could not withdraw or, failing such agreement, that it was not
    have complied with this law.

  1. e) That the arbitrators have resolved on issues not susceptible to

  1. f) That the award is contrary to public policy.

The same law states that the reasons for subparagraphs b, eyf, may be
pronounced ex officio, and that in the cases provided for in the cye, the
The annulment will only affect the pronouncements of the award relating to
issues not subject to the decision of the arbitrators or not susceptible to
arbitration, provided they can be separated from the others.

Article 17, paragraph III:

  1. a) When the arbitration agreement does not exist or is invalid due to lack of
    capacity of the parties or anything else.

  1. b) When the defendant has not been properly notified of
    the appointment of an arbitrator or the arbitration proceedings, or has not
    were able to assert their rights.

  1. c) When the arbitrators have resolved issues not submitted to their jurisdiction.
    decision.
  2. d) When the appointment of arbitrators or the arbitral procedure does not
    has complied with the agreement between the parties, or in the absence of such an agreement,
    It has not complied with the law.

  1. e) When the arbitrators have resolved on issues not susceptible to dispute

  1. f) When the award is contrary to public policy.

As can be seen, both legislations provide for the same causes.
of nullity for both procedures, and are restrictive (numerus
clausus) that is, outside of these no others could be admitted, given the
rescissory nature of the annulment action that only deprives the award of its
enforceability and res judicata force

Deadline

The time limit stipulated by law for taking action to nullify a
The award is due within one month of notification, according to Article 39
Article 5 of Law 489-08. In the event that a
correction, clarification or supplement to the award, from the notification of the
of the resolution. In the case of Law 181-09, this procedure does not vary.
There is a dilemma as to whether the deadline is straightforward or not, but the solution
The practice that has been reached is that article 1033 would apply, of
Code of Civil Procedure, which considers all time limits to be free.
have as their starting point the notification to a person or to their home.

Competition

Law 489-08, in its article 40, paragraph 1, grants the competence to the
Court of Appeal of the Department where the award was issued, to hear
of the action for annulment. Likewise, Law 181-09 does so, in its article
17 paragraph III, with the exception that it is filed before the Court of
Appeal that corresponds to the domicile of the Chamber of Commerce to which
the center that issued the award belongs to, and provided that the parties have not
waived this right in their arbitration agreement. In both cases, the decision that
The decision issued by the Court of Appeal regarding the nullity is susceptible to
appeal in cassation, provided it is not concerning an incidental award or
provisional, unless it is jointly with the underlying one, or the
The amount involved in it does not exceed 200 minimum wages of the most
high level of the private sector, as enshrined in Article 5 of Law 491-08 of
December 19, 2008, which modifies the Law of Procedure of
Cassation (This appeal suspends the appealed decision).

Procedure for filing a claim for annulment

The procedure for filing a claim to annul an arbitral award is governed
common law procedure (with the characteristics of an action)
main), since arbitration law has delegated that power to
to hear this case in the ordinary jurisdiction (Court of Appeal).

The action is exercised after the issuance of the arbitral award and before
that the deadlines established in both Law 489-08 and the
Law 181-09 (1 month), within the notification, and in the case of correction,
clarification or supplement to the award, after notification of said
resolution. They must be deposited and notified to both the court and the
The defendant must provide the supporting documents. The court must rule.
limiting itself to the nullities invoked by the legislations that it has to
see with arbitration (39 numeral 2, Law 489-08 and 17 paragraph III, Law
189-09).

Effects of the decision declaring the award null and void

The annulment not only has practical effects on the award, but also
regarding the dispute itself. For the parties, the annulment of the award may
signify the end of their litigation, or it may leave open the possibility of
resorting to ordinary courts, and even to a new arbitration. All of it.
It will depend on the grounds that support the declaration of nullity.

If the award is annulled due to invalidity, ineffectiveness or inapplicability of the agreement
In arbitration, access to arbitral justice is completely closed.
Arbitration would only be viable under a new arbitration agreement, since the agreement
The original agreement would be tainted by the annulment of the award. The pact
would become nonexistent, and without an agreement to support it, arbitration would be left without a foundation.
excluded.

Request for suspension of the execution of the award

The request for suspension of the arbitral award, according to our legislation in
In arbitration matters, proceedings are held before the presiding judge of the Court of Appeals.
as judge of the referrals (Art. 40, numeral 2, 3 and 4 of Law 489-08).
This request seeks to have any award that is being challenged in
The nullity may be suspended while said action is being heard. In the
In the case of decisions ordering provisional measures, they may not be
suspended32. The same law stipulates that between the term of the
notification (on a fixed date) of the suspended demand and the first
If the award is suspended by operation of law, it will be considered suspended. Furthermore, any appeal to the Supreme Court is categorically prohibited.
decisions33. When the request for suspension is granted, the party

32 Article 21 numeral 2 Law 489-08.

33 Same as Art. 40, numeral 4.
Applicant must provide a bond in cash or through a company
insurance company in the Dominican Republic. It is important to note that the
The suspension procedure is similar to both the Ad-hoc procedure and the
Institutional, due to its absence in the second.

 

Almost everything in law has a deadline, and yours is already running

Tell us what happened. We'll tell you which path applies and what to do right away, at no cost.

Evaluate my case
We reply within 24 hours

Tell us what is going on

Describe it in your own words. You don't need to know the legal term or have every document. Within 24 hours you will hear back on the options that apply and the deadlines that are running.

Also by phone, Monday to Friday from 8:00 am to 5:00 pm: +1 (809) 847-8731

Free case review