La guard protect the less, it doesn't solve a competition been arrested
When a child lives with grandparents and a parent requests custody , the decision must prioritize the child's best interests . The grandparents' affection and dedication are important, but they are not sufficient on their own to exclude a parent who meets the necessary requirements. Nor does parental authority eliminate the obligation to examine the child's actual circumstances.
La capacity The father's role should be assessed with evidence.
The court must analyze whether the parent can provide care, security, stability , and attention to the child 's needs . It is not enough to simply state that he is the father, nor to assume that grandparents always guarantee better conditions. Socio-family reports, care history , and other relevant evidence are necessary to substantiate the decision.
The jurisprudential criterion on Parents and grandparents
In judgment no. 1091, dated November 11, 2015, the First Chamber examined a conflict between maternal grandparents and the father. The ruling analyzed the father's fitness to care for his children and the need to demonstrate sufficient grounds for removing him from their care. The precedent shows that continued residence with the grandparents does not replace a concrete examination of the parenting circumstances.
The child's opinion should be heard and considered.
The child's wishes matter, according to their age and maturity, but must be considered alongside other factors. The judge must explain how that opinion and the family circumstances influence the solution. Protecting the child involves valuing their relationships, emotional well-being, and needs, without placing the sole responsibility for resolving the conflict on them.
Maintaining ties is also part of protection
Granting custody to a parent does not sever the emotional bond with grandparents. Depending on the circumstances, communication and visitation arrangements can be established that are compatible with the child's well-being. Similarly, custody granted to a third party must be based on verifiable reasons and can be reviewed through legal channels if circumstances change.
The request should focus on the child's well-being.
To claim or dispute custody, it is advisable to gather evidence regarding housing, health, education, and care, and to submit a proposal that addresses the child's situation. The decision rests with the competent court under the protective framework of Law 136-03. Sources: Supreme Court of Justice, First Chamber, judgment no. 1091, November 11, 2015 , and judicial criteria on the best interests of the child and the assessment of custody.
Carlos Felipe B.Managing partner and founder
