Transportation is a legal issue of great importance in commercial law, which can be approached from both a legal and an economic perspective . State intervention has steadily increased , to the point that virtually every state has had some direct involvement in transportation. This has further shaped the role of commercial law.
A transport contract is a contract in which a person is obliged to transport passengers and/or goods by land or sea in exchange for a set price.
Legally, the transport contract falls under the category of locatio operis, and is characterized by the particularity of the promised result , consisting of the transfer of people or things from one place to another.
The activity, the work , the provision of services, is considered a fungible and indivisible opus . It is fungible because the provider can carry it out by their own means and with their own company, or by using the means of others and an external organization.
In the case of the Dominican Republic, the issue of contracting transportation is even more complex, due to communication and organizational problems of the institutions in charge of controlling it.
Based on what has already been introduced, this report aims to explain more broadly what the transport contract is about, starting with concepts, characteristics and typologies, continuing with the transport contract in the Dominican Republic.
General Aspects of Transport
Transport is defined as the action and effect of moving goods from one place to another for an agreed price or freight .[1] Gine de Ruz Mendoza in his work entitled "Economics of Transport" defines it as the set of economic activities that allow the movement of goods through physical space by means of main modes: land, air, or sea, or some combination of these.
The transportation of goods should be viewed as an intermediary service, meaning that the success of other markets depends on its effectiveness, speed, and reliability. For this reason, transportation plays a crucial role between the production and marketing stages and should be seen as a tool within the trade system.
Since transportation is such a vital element in trade, the price of goods is affected by transportation costs. Therefore, to improve competitiveness in the international market, it is necessary not only to increase productivity but also to reduce the share of transportation costs in the final price. To achieve this, appropriate legal tools are needed to make transportation a more efficient and cost-effective process.
Nature and origin of transport
Multimodal transport has emerged basically for two reasons: [2]
1) The pressure of economic globalization and the definition of large regional markets.
2) Pressure from the transport sector itself to gain a larger market share, innovating in terms of means of transport and improving service levels.
The transport of goods has existed since the beginning of trade. For this reason, it is tedious to establish a specific date or detail the historical events that accompany the evolution of transport. The earliest forms of transport were based on unimodal transport. This is transport limited to only one mode, whether land, air, or water. In the Dominican Republic, there is still no legal framework for multimodal transport; instead, each mode of transport is regulated by its own specific legislation.
Contract of Transportation
A transport contract is defined as any contract by which a carrier undertakes, in exchange for payment of freight, to transport goods from one place to another.[3] Each transport contract, depending on the means of transport used, establishes its own particular clauses and creates a distinct relationship between the contracting parties. The transport contract is a consensual, bilateral agreement, for valuable consideration, and can be considered a variant of a contract for a specific work or service.[4] The unimodal transport contract is the simplest, since only one means of transport is used and the liability regime is determined by that means. However, when several modes of transport are combined to transport goods from their place of origin to their destination, it is called intermodal transport. Several forms of contracting have emerged from this mode of transport.
Transport contracts can be classified by their object, by the mode of transport they handle, by the geographical area that the transport covers, and by the applicable legal regime.
Below we present, in a schematic way, the classification according to each element and its subdivisions separately.
By its object:
- Cargo transport contract
- Passenger transport contract
Based on the method used:
- Maritime transport contract
- Land transportation contract
- Air transport contract
By geographical area covered by transport:
- National transport contract
- International transport contract
Based on the applicable legal regime:
- Unimodal transport contract
- Intermodal transport contract
ü Segmented
ü Combined
ü Multimodal
Everything would depend on how it is carried out, primarily considering the means used; from the schematization we will break it down according to the method used.
– Air Transport Contracts : when the means used is an aircraft, which is regulated by the Civil Aeronautics Law.
– Land Transport Contract : whether for goods or passengers, or both at the same time, regulated in both the Commercial Code and the Civil Code.
– Maritime Transport Contract : which is regulated by various international treaties and conventions, including the Commercial Code, and various laws that regulate both the customs regime and the ports.
– And to conclude, the river transport contract , although it is carried out, like maritime transport in ships, it generally involves not navigation at sea, but in inland rivers.
Something that all these contracts mentioned have in common is the responsibility of the carrier to transport or deliver to its destination safely and soundly, whether it be the person or the goods entrusted for transport.
Effects of Transport Contracts
Transport contracts have effects for both parties, the presenter and the shipper, creating obligations between them. In general, transport contracts create certain obligations that we can call "standard" regardless of the type of transport contract in question.
Conditions for the formation and testing of the transport contract.
By its nature, this type of contract is formed by the mere agreement of the parties ; it is a contract of adhesion, in which the conditions are predetermined and imposed by the carrier, leaving the passenger no option or alternative but to accept them. Proof of the transport contract, depending on its modalities, is established through a written document under private signature, which is generally pre-printed, limiting the user to simply affixing their signature. In the case of land transport, the passenger's presentation of their transport ticket or shipping receipt, in the case of air transport, the presentation of the transport ticket, and in maritime transport, the waybill or shipping manifest, are sufficient proof for these types of contracts.[5]
Multimodal Transport Contracts in the Dominican Republic
In the Dominican Republic, the application of multimodal transport contracts by transport companies is barely noticeable for several reasons. This is primarily due to the high risk involved in transporting goods by land, stemming from a lack of effective control and road safety, as well as the absence of an appropriate legal framework for this type of transport. Consequently, those qualified to offer multimodal transport services prefer to contract intermodal transport as a combined transport option to divide responsibility.
Of the many aspects of multimodal transport, especially its distinctive characteristics, the liability of the multimodal transport operator (MTO) is central to international discussions. It is a contentious issue when claims arise, typically for cargo damage, loss, or delivery delays.
Nature of the multimodal transport contract
The multimodal transport contract, according to the general classifications of contracts, is[6]:
ü Perfect synallagmatic because obligations arise between both parties
ü Consensual because it only requires the consent of the parties to be perfected.
ü For valuable consideration , because one of the parties is obliged to pay a fee for the service provided by the other party.
ü Commutative because the benefits received by the parties are certain.
ü Of adhesion , since its acceptance is manifested in the form of adherence to the conditions unilaterally set in the offer.
Obligations arising from the Transport Contract.
As Biaggi correctly states, this contract generates synallagmatic obligations on the part of:[7]
- Shipper or passengerThe shipper's obligations are simple: pay the transport price and observe and comply with any safety requirements imposed by administrative authorities or the carrier. The shipper's obligations are secured by a lien and a right of retention over the goods transported, granted by law to the carrier in the event of default by either the shipper or the consignee.
- And at the carrier's expense, As for their obligations, these are more complex, since their primary and essential obligation is to transport the person or goods safely, in good condition, within the agreed timeframe and to the agreed location. They will be presumed responsible not only for total or partial loss of the goods, but also for any damage or delays.
It would be up to the carrier to demonstrate the occurrence of one of the three causes of exemption from liability.
- Force majeure that exonerates the debtor from all obligations, understanding force majeure as any unforeseeable and insurmountable event that has made it impossible to perform the obligation, such as floods, earthquakes or an event originating from the government authority.
- The fault attributable to the shipper is a cause of exoneration of liability for the carrier, e.g., that the cargo is poorly packaged, or the dangerous nature of the goods to be transported has not been notified.
- The inherent defects of the cause, when dealing with merchandise susceptible to spontaneous deterioration, is the case, for example, of animals that may become ill during transport.
Three essential aspects stand out from the definition of a transport contract:
1- The personal elements of the transport contract are the carrier and the shipper, who is not necessarily the owner of the cargo.[8]
2- Regarding the formal element of the contract, it is consensual, since it is perfected by the agreement of wills. However, for evidentiary purposes, the carrier issues a waybill or bill of lading.
3- The essential elements of the contract are: the burden and the price. For the contract to be subject to voidability, the burden must be lawful, and it is preferable that the shipper specify the nature of the burden in the contract.
Legal status of transport contracts in the Dominican Republic
Trade imbalances, poor road infrastructure, lengthy border procedures, inadequate customs regime applicable to the container itself, and insecurity related to land movements of containers add to the costs and risks involved in the land leg of multimodal transport.
The integration of information and communication technologies (ICTs) into logistics and transportation services is another necessary step towards improving the competitiveness of the freight transport sector by providing information tools connected to global networks. However, ICTs require significant investment and trained personnel for database management.
In the Dominican Republic, this is being achieved through improved information flows and increased market transparency, particularly through online portals for contracting transportation and customs services. However, despite the use of these virtual portals, the Dominican legal framework does not yet utilize them as a tool to expedite the transportation process; it merely considers them as a source of information and consultation.
Value of non-liability clauses in the Transport Contract.
In principle, any clause exonerating the carrier from liability in the performance of the transport contract must be considered null and void, and consequently, it is impossible to be exonerated from any loss, breach, or damage. However, liability may be waived if it is due to delay, such as in clauses that limit liability by stipulating a predetermined amount to cover its faults. But the Court of Cassation, in its jurisprudence, has chosen to reject this type of limited liability clause.
This research has allowed us to understand that transportation is undoubtedly one of the most important legal issues in the study of commercial law. This analysis of transportation has been conducted from a strictly legal perspective (although it can also be considered from an economic standpoint), due to our focus on the transportation contract itself. Because of the fundamental role that the transportation of goods or people plays in economic and social life, the need has arisen to assign significant legal responsibilities to those who undertake this activity, thus giving rise to the transportation contract.
In transport contracts, as you may have noticed, there is participation of essential elements, which are common to all civil or commercial contracts in general, namely, the subjects and their capacity to contract, consent, cause, object, purpose and form; thus making them more familiar to us.
Thanks to these commercial contracts for the transport of goods or people, major conflicts, which often arise in commercial matters due to the many unforeseen circumstances that can occur, have been avoided and resolved. Thus, it can be concluded that well-drafted transport contracts are one of the most effective ways to prevent such problems. To this end, scholars of commercial law should delve deeper into the subject and emphasize the crucial importance of transport contracts within the current social structure, where their role is so prominent that it would be foolish to question the vital part that transport plays in the development of nations.
Bibliographic sources
[1]Royal Spanish Academy, dictionary of the Spanish language 2001.
[2]Baena, Josep, international transport, Barcelona, Logis.book publishing house, 2002, p.33
[3] United Nations Convention on the Contract for the International Carriage of Goods.
[4] Biaggi Lama, Juan Alfredo. Manual of Dominican Commercial Law, p. 488.
[5]Biaggi Lama, Juan Alfredo. Manual of Dominican Commercial Law, p. 489.
[6] García Campos, Marie Linnete, The contractual responsibility of the maritime carrier of goods in the Dominican Republic, Santo Domingo, 1992, p. 35
[7]Biaggi Lama, Juan Alfredo. Manual of Dominican Commercial Law, p. 491
[8]Baena, Josep, "international transport" Barcelona, Logis Book Publishing House, 2002, p. 24
Made by: Natalia Beltré, Jeury Cruz, Mérilon Tineo Guisard
In Santo Domingo, Dominican Republic, we have the most comprehensive and effective team of lawyers to advise you on matters of Civil Procedure and Common Law. Here at Carlos Felipe Law Firm SRL , we evaluate your case free of charge and without obligation. Call us at 809-847-8731 or write to us at info@fc-abogados.com . You can also chat with us here.
Carlos Felipe B.Managing partner and founder

