God, Fatherland and Liberty Dominican Republic In the Name of the Republic, the Supreme Court of Justice, regularly constituted by Judges Jorge A. Subero Isa, President; Rafael Luciano Pichardo, First Substitute President; Eglys Margarita Esmurdoc, Second Substitute President; Hugo Álvarez Valencia, Margarita A. Tavares, Julio Ibarra Ríos, Enilda Reyes Pérez, Julio Aníbal Suárez, Víctor José Castellanos Estrella, Ana Rosa Bergés Dreyfous, Edgar Hernández Mejía and Pedro Romero Confesor, assisted by the Secretary General, in the Courtroom where it holds its hearings, in the city of Santo Domingo de Guzmán, National District, today September 15, 2005, the 162nd year of Independence and the 143rd year of the Restoration, issues in Council Chamber, the following resolution: Having seen, article 8 numeral 2 letters b, c, dyg, and 8.4 of the Constitution of the Republic; Having seen, the Code of Criminal Procedure instituted by Law 76-02; Having seen, article 29, paragraph 2 of Law 821 on Judicial Organization; Having seen, Law No. 25-91, Organic Law of the Supreme Court of Justice, of October 15, 1991, amended by Law No. 156-97, of July 10, 1997; Having seen, articles 7.1 and 7.2 of the American Convention on Human Rights, or Pact of San José, of November 22, 1969, duly approved by the National Congress through Resolution No. 739 of December 25, 1977 and published in the Official Gazette No. 9460 of February 11, 1978; Having seen, Articles 8, 9, 10 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, of December 16, 1966, duly approved by the National Congress through Resolution No. 684 of October 27, 1977 and published in the Official Gazette No. 9451 of November 12, 1977; Whereas, the Constitution assumes this dimension, establishing in its article 8 that: “The effective protection of the rights of the human person and the maintenance of the means that allow them to progressively perfect themselves within an order of individual liberty and social justice, compatible with public order, the general welfare, and the rights of all are recognized as the main purpose of the State”; Whereas, these guarantees seek to ensure that no person may be deprived of defending their violated right and claiming redress before the courts of justice; nor may they be subjected by the State, its authorities and jurisdictional bodies to an arbitrary and unreasonable penalty, procedure or treatment; Whereas, in consideration of the guarantee of individual security enshrined in Art. 8.2 of the Constitution, the exercise of public action, particularly in the investigation phase, is limited by judicial control; Whereas, it is necessary to regulate everything related to the hearings that must be held during the preparatory stage, especially those related to coercive measures, which must be ordered in order to ensure the appearance of the accused at the procedural acts and the execution of the sentence; Whereas, for such purposes and to comply with the constitutional principle of judiciality, it is essential to achieve the immediate intervention of a judge to decide on the situation of the accused who are deprived of liberty, as well as for those against whom it is intended to exercise some type of criminal coercion; Whereas, it is necessary to expedite the processes through the implementation of mechanisms that allow for the rapid processing and decision of requests regarding coercive measures. Similarly, it is necessary to establish practices regarding the holding of hearings during the preparatory stage in order to achieve greater speed and efficiency in the understanding of the processes; given that, on the other hand, there has been an excessive and unreasonable use of the procedural mechanism of the review of coercive measures in forensic practice, for which reason it is necessary to implement controls that allow its correct functioning, so that it can serve the purpose for which it was created. Therefore, it resolves: CHAPTER I: General Provisions Article 1. Denomination. This resolution contains the Regulation on Coercive Measures and Holding of Hearings during the Preparatory Stage. Article 2. In accordance with the provisions contained in the American Convention on Human Rights and the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, in articles 8.2, paragraphs b), c), d), e), g) and 8.4 of the Constitution of the Republic and articles 14, 15, 16, 222 to 245 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, this regulation is adopted with the purpose of establishing the minimum guidelines for the functioning and operation of the investigating judges, in order to decide on requests for coercive measures, as well as the review of the same both in cases where they are ordered at the request of a party, and when they must be made ex officio by the judge in charge. Article 3. Applicability. This regulation applies to all criminal jurisdictions competent to hear cases concerning the application, review, revocation, modification or substitution of coercive measures; likewise, it applies, as relevant, to the operation of the system for any other hearing or proceeding held during the preparatory procedure, in accordance with the provisions of Article 292 of the Criminal Procedure Code, except as indicated in this regulation of the preliminary hearing. CHAPTER II: COMPETENCE: Scope and extension Article 4. Scope and extent. The Investigating Judge resolves: • Requests for coercive measures made by the public prosecutor or the complaining party; • Review of coercive measures made at the request of the accused; • Review of coercive measures made ex officio with respect to any coercive measure, provided that it benefits the accused; • Mandatory review of preventive detention. CELEBRATION OF THE HEARING Article 5. Petition. The request for the application of a coercive measure can be made by both the public prosecutor and the victim acting as a plaintiff. The request must be a simple written document without special formalities, containing the personal data of the accused, a concise account of the fact and its legal classification with the supporting evidence, the type of measure required and, if applicable, the request for arrest. Paragraph: The application may be made by means of a written document deposited in the court clerk's office in person, via fax, email or any other means established in the regulations for the processing of notifications, summonses and judicial communications. Article 6. Setting the hearing date and summons. Upon receiving the request, the judge will immediately proceed to set a hearing date, and the clerk must summon all persons who must attend. The summons must contain the date of the hearing and all the elements that allow the recipient to adequately prepare their means of defense or attack. Article 7. Audience preparation. Prior to the time of the hearing, the secretary will ensure the availability of the following elements: • A suitable place for holding the hearing. • The equipment necessary for holding the hearings, such as a computer, consumable materials, pens, etc. • The assistant secretary who will participate in the hearing. • The documentary background of the process. • Contact, by any means, those in charge of the transfer of the accused, if they are detained, and ensure their timely appearance at the hearing. • Contact, by any means, the defense attorney, the prosecutor, and the plaintiff to ensure their presence at the scheduled time for the hearing. •
In short, to ensure that all persons whose attendance is a condition for the holding of the hearing actually attend it, as well as that every other condition or material element necessary for the holding of the hearing is available at the time of the holding of the hearing. Article 8. The judge who is assigned a request for a coercive measure will set the hearing within the following terms: 1. If the person against whom the petition is directed is under arrest, the hearing will be held as soon as the accused is presented to him. 2 If the person against whom the request is made is at liberty, the hearing will be held no later than three working days after the request. Article 9. Scope of discussion. For the imposition of a coercive measure, during the hearing the duly summoned parties will be heard exclusively on the following points: 1) The occurrence of an act classified as a criminal offense. 2) Regarding the probable participation of the accused in the act, as perpetrator or accomplice. 3) That the offense carries a penalty of imprisonment, and 4) Reasonable presumption that the accused will appear at the acts of the procedure and at the pronouncement of the sentence. Paragraph: Where applicable, the rules of the trial apply, adapted to the simplicity of the hearing for coercive measures. The judge will indicate to the parties the necessary time to express their opinion on the points submitted for discussion, taking into account the degree of complexity of the matter to be decided. Article 10. Presentation of evidence. For the purpose of determining the probability of issuing coercive measures, it will be sufficient for the parties to inform the judge regarding the content and value of the evidence obtained so far. Paragraph: In cases where a violation of due process is invoked, the production of testimonial evidence may exceptionally be admitted immediately, at the judge's discretion. RESOLUTION ON THE JUDGE'S DECISION Article 11. The decision regarding the coercive measure must, in any case, be rendered at the end of the hearing after the conclusions of the parties, and the judge cannot reserve the ruling for a later day. Article 12. Content of the resolution. The resolution must conform to the requirements set forth in Article 231 of the Criminal Procedure Code. It can be handwritten by the judge or in pre-designed forms that meet the indicated legal requirements. Paragraph: The resolution, in accordance with the provisions of Article 24 of the Criminal Procedure Code, must clearly and precisely contain the reasons why the judge opted for a particular solution. Article 13. The record referred to in article 232 of the Criminal Procedure Code must be drawn up in all cases in which the coercive measure imposed is neither preventive imprisonment nor house arrest with surveillance. For these purposes, the special form created for this purpose will be used. Article 14. Notification of the resolution. Reading the resolution after the hearing constitutes notification, provided that a copy of it is issued to the parties involved. Article 15. From the Review of Coercive Measures. All coercive measures may be reviewed at the request of a party, or ex officio for the benefit of the accused. Prior to setting the hearing and in accordance with the provisions of articles 238, 239 and 240 of the Criminal Procedure Code, the judge will consider its admissibility, provided that the applicant meets the following conditions: 1. Precise determination of facts, evidence or assumptions that determine the variation of the conditions that justified the imposition of the measure. 2. Presentation of certification that no appeal has been filed, and if an appeal has been filed, the Court's decision must be presented. Paragraph I. In all cases where the judge admits a request for review of a coercive measure, a hearing will only be scheduled when it involves preventive detention or house arrest, as provided in article 8240 of the Criminal Procedure Code, or when the review seeks the imposition of one of these measures. In all other cases, the matter will be resolved administratively in accordance with Article 238 of the aforementioned legal instrument. Both this admissibility decision and the request for review must be notified to all parties. Paragraph II. The review hearing will be conducted in accordance with the rules for hearings on coercive measures. Paragraph III. If the Judge decides not to accept the request for review because the circumstances that gave rise to the measure have not changed, he will issue a reasoned order declaring the request inadmissible and will notify the applicant. If it deems it admissible, it will proceed to set a hearing for its information. Article 16. The mandatory review of pretrial detention is governed by the provisions of Article 239 of the Criminal Procedure Code. In these cases, the court clerk must issue a certificate stating whether the decision that imposed the coercive measure has been subject to review or appeal. If an appeal has been filed, the Court's decision must be provided to the judge in order to determine the length of the review period and jurisdiction. Article 17. This regulation applies equally to all cases in which a hearing must be held during the preparatory stage, taking into account the nature and particularities of the cases submitted to the investigating judge, except for the provisions for the preliminary hearing, which is governed by the provisions of Article 300 of the Criminal Procedure Code. CHAPTER III: FINAL PROVISIONS Article 18. Binding force of the regulation. This regulation shall be mandatory and uniformly applied in all departments and judicial districts. Article 19. Supplementary application. For cases and situations not covered by these regulations, the rules of common law will apply in a supplementary manner. Article 20. Orders that this resolution be communicated to the General Directorate of the Judicial Career and to the Attorney General's Office for compliance purposes, and that it be published in the Judicial Bulletin for general knowledge. George A. Subero Isa Rafael Luciano Pichardo Eglys Margarita Esmurdoc Hugo Álvarez Valencia Margarita A. Tavares Julio Ibarra Ríos Enilda Reyes Pérez Juan Luperón Vásquez Dulce Ma. Rodríguez de Goris Julio Aníbal Suárez Víctor José Castellanos Ana Rosa Bergés D. Edgar Hernández Mejía Darío O. Fernández Espinal Pedro Romero Confesor José E. Hernández Machado Grimalda Acosta, General Secretary. This resolution has been given and signed by the judges listed above, on the day, month and year expressed therein, which I, the General Secretary, certify.
In the Dominican Republic, we have the most comprehensive and effective team of legal professionals to defend your rights. Here at Carlos Felipe Law Firm SR L , we offer a free, no-obligation consultation. To evaluate your case, call us at 809-847-8731 or email us at info@fc-abogados.com . You can also chat with us here.
Carlos Felipe B.Managing partner and founder