Insult and defamation: crime

Written by Carlos Felipe17 min read

Images for post 56

Images for post 56

What we call crime by defamation and we define injury as a penalty which is considered when a person understands that certain insights u opinion harm or can produce qualitative damage to the moral or the honor of one or more persons; they must be cited before presenting a thesis or opinion on what defamation and slander represent in our bar code and law of expression and dissemination of thought that the to date Today is showing the sanctions that they present within the jurisdiction Dominican. 

LA DEFAMATION AND THE INJURY 
El article 367 of the Code Criminal defines it as, I quote: "Defamation is the allegation o imputation a done, which attacks the honor or reputation of the person or of body to which it is imputed. Any insulting expression, any invective or insult is considered an insult. term of contempt, which does not imply the imputation of a specific act.". End of quote.

The defamer is defined as a specific act, whether true or false, that attacks a person's honor or reputation. Insult exists simply by using an offensive or derogatory expression against a person, without imputing a specific act, as defined in Article 373, which states: "For the preceding provisions to apply, the defamation or insult must be public. Insults that do not have the dual character of being public and imputing a specific defect will be punished with simple police penalties." End of quote.

The crime of defamation and slander is a sanction applied when a person believes that certain information or opinions have damaged their reputation. This legislation establishes a series of exceptions that exempt the offender from punishment, but in no case does it completely eliminate the crime.

The main demand is the elimination of criminal defamation laws, not just any defamation law. The goal is to achieve its decriminalization, meaning that it is no longer considered a crime and therefore does not carry prison sentences.

COMMON CONSTITUTIVE ELEMENT OF DEFAMATION AND SLANDER 
Publicity: Defamation and slander against private individuals do not constitute crimes per se when they are not committed publicly. In the absence of the element of publicity, slander constitutes a simple police infraction according to Article 373. Defamation itself, when it is not committed publicly, changes in nature in a certain sense and is sanctioned as simple slander. In accordance with the provisions of Article 471, paragraph 16 of the Penal Code, I quote:  "Those who, without having been provoked, insult any person, except in the cases provided for in the treaty on defamation and slander, will be punished with a fine of one peso." End of quote.

Public places are those frequented by everyone or where anyone can have access at any time. Public places by destination are those accessible to all persons who wish to enter them for a specific purpose. They differ from the former in that publicity is not inherent to their nature: at a certain point, they may cease to be open to the public. To determine the difference, at the time of the offense, they were open to the public. In general, private places can occasionally become public places; it is only a question of fact that falls to the Court of Cassation to verify whether the public nature of the defamation results from the factual circumstances established by the lower court judges.

SPECIAL CONSTITUTIVE ELEMENTS OF THE DEFAMATION

  • The allegation or imputation of a specific fact

An allegation is an assertion made on the basis of a public rumor or a mere assumption, while a challenge is a personal statement based on firm personal knowledge.

These accusations must be based on a specific fact, the truth or falsity of which can be verified. If someone is accused of having been convicted of a crime, it may be either true or false. A specific, verifiable fact has been stated; therefore, defamation has been committed, and such defamation is punishable, even if presented in a disguised form or by way of insinuation.

  • An act that involves an attack on honor or reputation

It attacks honor when it is contrary to property, loyalty, or honesty, regardless of whether it is punishable under criminal law. This includes allegations that a citizen might use their influence to be exempted from military service or that they acted in bad faith in business. It attacks reputation when it harms a person's ethical standing, that is, when it is likely to compromise their social or professional position. This is an imputation of facts contrary to the person's reputation.

  • The designation of the person or body to whom the act is attributed

It is not necessary for the person to be expressly named; it is sufficient that the person in question can be clearly and precisely identified. When defamation is directed against a legal entity or a group, a distinction must be made. If the accusation is made in such a way as to attack each member of the group, each member may sue the defamer.

  • The culpable intent

It is always required, even in the absence of publicity, when defamation becomes a simple infraction, regardless of the motive. This criminal intent is presumed, and it is the defendant who bears the burden of proving that this intent does not exist, by presenting facts justified by their good faith. The trial judges, under the control of the Court of Cassation, will assess the value of the alleged justified facts.

If one of the four elements mentioned above is missing, the offense ceases to exist. Consequently, the public action is extinguished and cannot be brought against the perpetrator, but the act may constitute a civil wrong or a quasi-wrong. The civil action for damages may be brought before the civil courts.

SPECIAL CONSTITUTIVE ELEMENTS OF INJURY 

  • Insulting expression, term of contempt or invective

For the crime of insulting individuals to exist, according to Article 373 of the Penal Code, the offensive expression, the term of contempt, or the invective must have the dual character of being public and imputing a specific vice. However, the law does not require, as in the case of defamation, the imputation of a precise act. It matters little whether the offensive expression actually attacks the honor or reputation of the aggrieved person. The insulting nature stems from its violence or vulgarity.

  • Designation of the injured person

Like defamation, insult must be directed against a person or a legal entity. Like defamation, insult can consist of words or deeds, but it can also consist of writings, because despite the deficiency of the legal wording, there can be no doubt as to the legislator's intent to include in the definition of insult written imputations directed at a person or a legal entity. Articles 367 and 369 refer to living persons, I quote: (367) “ Defamation is the allegation or imputation of a fact that attacks the honor or reputation of the person or entity to which it is imputed.” "An insult is defined as any offensive expression, any invective or term of contempt, that does not contain the imputation of a specific fact" and (369) "Defamation or insult made against Deputies or Representatives to Congress, Secretaries of State, Magistrates of the Supreme Court or of the courts of first instance, or the Heads and Sovereigns of friendly nations, shall be punished with imprisonment from one to six months and a fine of fifty pesos." End of quote.

Indeed, Articles 367 and 369 refer to living persons, since only they can be harmed by defamation or slander. This is how the Supreme Court of Justice expressed itself in the judgment it issued on January 28, 1927, acting as the Court of Cassation (Judicial Bulletin No. 198, page 13). What is protected is not the reputation or memory of the deceased, but rather the heirs when they prove they have suffered perjury.

  • Guilty intent

As in the case of defamation, the perpetrator of the insult must have acted with culpable intent. There can be no insult without intent to insult. Intent is presumed. The specific intent of the insult consists of two circumstances:

A) The knowledge that the expressions used or actions performed commonly serve to dishonor or offend.
B) That it has been but done or executed in an offensive manner.

  • Offenses of libel

Any insult that does not exhibit the dual characteristics of being public and imputing a specific defect constitutes a violation of the law against insult, as explained in Article 373, final paragraph. Justices of the peace are competent to judge and sentence those guilty of the violation against the law against insult with simple police penalties. They cease to have this jurisdiction when the circumstance of publicity of the insult is present, in which case the courts of first instance have jurisdiction.

JURISDICTION OVER DEFAMATION AND SLANDER 

The jurisprudence Judicial Bulletin 749, page 823, April 1973, does not say that the crime of defamation and slander is within the jurisdiction of the Court of First Instance and when this court is declared incompetent the court seized by the appeal must take up the merits and say so, I quote: "CONSIDERING, that the examination of the challenged ruling reveals that the facts attributed to the defendant were defamation and slander, punishable by correctional prison sentences, according to article 371 of the Penal Code, for which reason its knowledge and ruling corresponded to the court of first instance, and not to the justice of the peace, as the third criminal chamber, seized of the case, had erroneously understood; that under these conditions, the court acts, since the aforementioned chamber, upon hearing the defendant's objection, did not judge the case on its merits, but merely referred it to the Justice of the Peace Court, due to the annulment of the first instance ruling, the need to take up the merits and decide them; that, by not doing so, it disregarded Article 215 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, and therefore the challenged sentence must be overturned, with the exception of the offense of defamation, which falls under the jurisdiction of the Justice of the Peace Court, as expressed in Article 471, paragraph 16 of the Penal Code. End of quote.

Article 371, cited in the jurisprudence, states: "Defamation against private individuals shall be punished with imprisonment from six days to three months and a fine of five to twenty-five pesos." End of quote.

Article 215 of the Code of Criminal Procedure mentioned in the jurisprudence, I quote: "If the sentence is annulled due to a violation or unremedied omission of forms prescribed by law under penalty of nullity, the Court shall rule on the merits." End of quote.

A ruling by the Supreme Court of Justice (Judicial Bulletin 399, page 931, of the year 1943) presents as a rule that defamation itself, when it is not carried out publicly, changes in a certain sense of nature and is sanctioned as simple slander, that is, as the contravention of slander.

THE REGIME OF CIVIL LIABILITY AND INJURY

The civil liability regime established in Law 6132 on freedom of expression and dissemination of thought is based on regulating how thoughts must be expressed in writing and subsequently published, that is, in writing or in any other form already established in Article 23, which states: “Persons who have directly incited the perpetrator or perpetrators of an act classified as a crime or offense, if the incitement is followed by the commission of the crime or offense, shall be punished as accomplices thereto.”… End of quote. Meanwhile, the liability regime of Article 367 of the Penal Code is based on the principle that defamation, in violation of this article, occurs when something is verbally alleged that is detrimental to the reputation of a natural or legal person.

PENALTIES FOR DEFAMATION AND SLANDER 

The penalties established by Law 6132 in its Article 33, I quote: “Defamation committed against individuals by one of the means listed in Articles 23 and 29 shall be punished with imprisonment for fifteen days to six months and a fine of RD$25.00 to RD$200.00, or with one of these two penalties only. Defamation committed by the same means against a group of people, not designated by Article 31 of this law, but who belong by origin to a particular race or religion, shall be punished with imprisonment for one month to one year and a fine of RD$25.00 to RD$200.00, when its purpose is to incite feelings of hatred in the population.” End of quote.

And in some special cases, such as Article 26 of said law, I quote: “Offenses against the President of the Republic by any of the means stated in Article 23 shall be punished with imprisonment for three months to one year and a fine of RD$100.00 to RD$1,000.00, or with only one of the two penalties. The penalties provided for in this same article are applicable to offenses against the person who exercises some or all of the prerogatives of the President of the Republic.” End of quote.

In the case of defamation, Articles 34 and 35 of Law 6132 express the following, I quote: (34.) "Insults committed by the same means against the organizations or persons designated by Articles 30 and 31 of this law shall be punished with a prison sentence of six days to three months and a fine of RD$6.00 to RD$60.00 or with only one of these two penalties." and (35) "Insults committed in the manner established in Article 34, to the detriment of individuals, when not preceded by provocation, shall be punished with five days to two months of imprisonment and a fine of RD$6.00 to RD$50.00, or with only one of these penalties. The maximum penalty shall be 6 months and the maximum fine shall be RD$100.00, if the insult was committed with the purpose of provoking feelings of hatred in the population, to the detriment of a group of people who, by their origin, belong to a certain race or religion." End of quote.

The statute of limitations for criminal prosecution in cases of defamation and slander, according to the Code of Criminal Procedure, the Penal Code, and Law 6132 on freedom of expression and dissemination of thought, is three years. The statute of limitations for the crime of defamation, as defined in Article 367 of the Penal Code, being a misdemeanor offense, is in accordance with the statute of limitations for misdemeanor offenses.

Law 6132 of December 19, 1962, stipulates that legal actions based on said law must be initiated within two months following the dissemination of the statements in question. Indeed, Article 61 of Law 6132 prescribes, and I quote: “Public action and civil action resulting from the crimes and offenses provided for in this law shall be barred by the statute of limitations after two months have elapsed, counting from the day on which they were committed or from the day of the last act of prosecution, if any.” End of quote.

The Code of Criminal Procedure, or Law 76-02, was enacted on July 19, 2002, meaning it is subsequent to Law 6132 and its provisions. Article 45 of said Code of Criminal Procedure (Law 76-02) states, and I quote: «PrescriptionThe statute of limitations for criminal prosecution is: 1. Upon the expiration of a period equal to the maximum sentence, in the case of offenses punishable by imprisonment, provided that in no case may this period exceed ten years or be less than three. 2. Upon the expiration of a period of one year in the case of offenses punishable by non-custodial sentences or arrest. End of quote.

From the comparative reading and combined interpretation of Article 45 of the Criminal Procedure Code and Article 33 of Law 6132, as previously stated, it is clear that the action to prosecute defamation in this case prescribes at the end of the maximum applicable penalty, which in this case is six months.

The final part of Article 449, paragraph 3 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (or Law 76-02) expressly prescribes, and I quote: “ Final Provisions. All other provisions of Special Law that are contrary to this code are hereby repealed.” End of quote.

Article 57 of the Code of Criminal Procedure states: “ Exclusivity and Universality. The exclusive and universal jurisdiction of the criminal courts includes the adjudication of all punishable acts and omissions provided for in the Criminal Code and in Special Criminal Legislation, and the execution of their judgments and rulings, as established by this Code. The procedural rules established in this Code apply to the investigation, adjudication, and judgment of any punishable act, regardless of its nature or the accused, including members of the Armed Forces and the National Police, even when the punishable acts attributed to them were committed in the exercise of their duties and without prejudice to the strictly disciplinary powers of the bodies to which they belong. Offenses and procedures in cases involving children and adolescents are governed by their Special Law.” End of quote

As can be seen, the Criminal Procedure Code repealed all procedural aspects of all special laws that were or are contrary to it, with the exception of the Special Legislation for Minors.

This repeal is express: One only needs to examine the aforementioned articles 449 and 57: It repealed any procedural provision of any Special Law that is contrary to it, with the exception of the Special Legislation for Minors.

In Santo Domingo, Dominican Republic, we have the most comprehensive and effective team of lawyers to advise you on matters of Civil Procedure and Common Law. Here at Carlos Felipe Law Firm SRL , we evaluate your case free of charge and without obligation. Call us at 809-847-8731 or write to us at info@fc-abogados.com . You can also chat with us here.

Almost everything in law has a deadline, and yours is already running

Tell us what happened. We'll tell you which path applies and what to do right away, at no cost.

Evaluate my case
We reply within 24 hours

Tell us what is going on

Describe it in your own words. You don't need to know the legal term or have every document. Within 24 hours you will hear back on the options that apply and the deadlines that are running.

Also by phone, Monday to Friday from 8:00 am to 5:00 pm: +1 (809) 847-8731

Free case review